"Do you understand," Desai asked, with the patience of a woman who had asked this question in other rooms to other men and had stopped expecting it to land, "that if he had announced himself, every other passenger you ever challenged would still have had no recourse, because the recourse would have belonged to the owner alone?"
"I understand that is the committee's view," Moser said. "My view is simpler. I challenged a passenger I believed did not belong in that seat. I was wrong about the passenger. The company had information that would have corrected me and had arranged its information so that nobody read it, including me. For that, I have been relieved, and investigated, and I expect I am finished, and I will tell you the thing I will tell the hearing, Ms. Desai, so that it is somewhere in your record in my words: I was not a secret. I did what I did at the doors of aircraft, in front of crews and agents and passengers, for fourteen years, in the open, on the record of every delay I ever took for it. If it was wrong, it was wrong in the open, in a company that watched it happen and filed it under feedback. Let the report say that too, next to my name. Let it say all the names. That is what the purser asked for, I am told. On that, Ms. Bergman and I are in complete agreement."
The employment hearing was held in the seventh week, in a room at headquarters with the blinds drawn, under the collective bargaining agreement's machinery, which the company honored to the letter and the union worked to the letter, as both sides had agreed in advance that this case, of all cases, would be done by the book so that the book would be the thing that survived it. Samuel did not attend. His recusal was read into the record at the opening by the hearing officer, a fleet chief pilot from another base, along with the special committee's instruction that the panel decide on the evidence and the evidence alone, without regard to the identity of the passenger on Flight 207, a sentence the hearing officer read twice, because he wanted it understood that the company was not asking him to avenge an owner. It was asking him to judge a captain.
The evidence took two days. The incident file, minute by minute. Bergman's testimony, given under the same warning as her interview, in which she described the morning without adjectives and then, asked by the union's counsel whether she had borne the captain ill will before that day, answered that she had filed a complaint about him in 2017 and had received no answer, and that the absence of the answer, and not the man, was what she had carried into that cabin. Pappas's testimony and his notebook, admitted as an exhibit, the three names in the back in a pilot's hand. The raw complaint history, nine entries across eight years, with the company's own routing records laid beside them so that the panel could see, in the company's hand, what had been done with each: received, stamped, rerouted, uncounted, unanswered. Desai's factual summary, admitted by stipulation, which established the architecture in which the nine had vanished, and which took care, because Desai took care, to record what Moser had said in his own defense about the silence, and to record it fairly.
Moser testified on the second day. He did not perform remorse, and the panel noted it, and he did not perform defiance either, which the panel also noted. He acknowledged the facts of Flight 207 as the file stated them, every one. He acknowledged the Detroit reseating in 2017 and two of the other incidents as matters of judgment he would defend again on the merits as he understood them at the time. What he contested, with his counsel's full support, was the proposition that a pattern he was never shown could be the cause of his termination. "A company that wants to fire a man for a pattern," he said, "has to show him the pattern once, on the record, with a chance to answer it. That is not a technicality. That is the whole difference between a discipline system and an ambush. This company showed me commendations. It showed me nothing else for fourteen years, because it had arranged, in another department, by another man's hand, that there would be nothing to show. Fire me for the morning of Flight 207, if the contract allows it, for the order I gave and the documents I would not read. But the nine complaints are the company's confession, not mine, and I will grieve any finding that pretends otherwise, and I will win or lose that grievance on its merits and accept the result as a professional. I want that in the record too. I am not asking this panel for mercy. I am asking it to be accurate. Accuracy is the entire subject of this proceeding, as I understand it. It has been the subject of every proceeding in this company since September."