Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The lawsuit came in 1999 and went away in 2000 the way weather goes away from a place that keeps its windows shut. Scott, by then a freshman at college on the money that was already getting thin, knew of it as a pressure in the house rather than an event: lawyers' envelopes on the counter, his father's long silences at the table, a new and specific flatness in his mother's voice when the mail came. And then one Saturday there was a different envelope and his father sat with it a long time and said, "It is finished," and his mother said, "Good," in the tone of a woman closing a door against a storm, and after that the subject of Carroway Airlines was, by treaty, the weather in another state. Robert Ellery went to work for a freight forwarder, then for a trucking company, dispatching trucks with the same care he had given airplanes, and if the work was smaller he never said so in Scott's hearing. He grew older in the way of men who have been set down hard: not bitter in any way you could point to, just quieter each year, a radio being turned down by degrees, until at some point the family understood that the silences had stopped being about anything and had become the man. He died in 2009, of his heart, in his sleep, in the house in the suburbs, with the file still sealed in a courthouse he had walked out of nine years before. Scott was twenty-eight, a first officer at a regional airline, and at the funeral a man from the old dispatch office, retired, white-headed, came through the line and held Scott's hand in both of his and said, "Your dad was careful. I want that said in a room, once." Scott thanked him, and did nothing with the sentence, and the sentence went into the drawer with everything else.

That Scott then went to work for Carroway, four years later, was a decision the family never debated, which was how the Ellerys debated the largest things. The regional was folding its Houston base; Carroway was hiring; a captain Scott respected told him the name would be a problem exactly once, at the interview, and after that it would be a problem only on the days Scott made it one. The interview panel had included a man from safety who had asked, with the air of a person discharging a duty, whether Scott had any feelings about the company's history that would affect his work, and Scott had said, "My father was a dispatcher here. He was fired after Flight 117. I fly the book they give me," and the panel had moved on, and for nineteen years the arrangement had held. He had flown with men who had flown with Patrick Keneally. Once, early on, a gray-bearded captain in the last year before retirement had looked at Scott's badge over the glare shield and said, "Ellery. Your old man ever tell you about the night the 117 went down?" and Scott had said, "No, sir. He never did," which was a lie by the length of one half-heard sentence in a dark hallway, and the old captain had nodded as if that settled the accounts of both families, and said, "Probably just as well," and Scott had let the lie stand for fifteen years, because it was load-bearing too: as long as his father had never said anything, there was nothing Scott was failing to carry. It was the perfect Ellery arrangement. Everyone in the family had signed it. His mother had signed it at the sink with her back turned. And it had taken an eighty-two-year-old man in a plastic sleeve to walk the one visible line of the actual file into the first-class cabin and hold it out at the end of an arm that did not shake, and reduce the whole architecture, the corridor, the quiet, the treaties, to what it had always been: a family waiting for somebody else to say the first word, while the man who had said it first, in writing, at 19:42 on the night it happened, lay nine years dead with his sentence under seal.

Scott drove home from the airport hotel on Wednesday morning with the chief pilot's meeting still ahead of him on Friday, and he did not go to his own apartment. He drove the beltway around to the suburb that had been rebuilt twice since his childhood into a larger version of itself, and he parked in the driveway of his mother's house, and he sat in the truck for a full minute assembling the question he had come to ask, which turned out to be no more complicated at the end of twenty-eight years than it had been at the beginning. His mother opened the door before he knocked, because she had heard the truck, because she always heard everything on that street, because she had been standing at windows for a very long time. "You are not in uniform," Diane Ellery said, looking at yesterday's shirt. "No," Scott said. "I need to ask you about the night it happened. I need to ask it in the kitchen, and I need you to answer it the way it was, and not the way we keep it." His mother looked at him then with an expression he had seen exactly once before, at a funeral home in 2009 when the retired dispatcher had said his sentence in the room, and she stepped back from the door and let her son into the house.

News in the same category

Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

45 Part