The memo was read aloud in a lawyer's office in downtown Houston, in a conference room with a view of nothing, by a young associate of the review's counsel who had been given the task, Scott suspected, precisely because her voice had no history in it. The review's procedures had been set out by Dale Hutchinson in a memorandum so dry it was almost courteous: the families would hear the central documents read in full, in the presence of the panel's counsel, before any findings were drafted; nothing would be summarized to them in advance; the dead would be allowed to speak in the order they had spoken. Hutchinson himself was there, seventy-eight, upright as a fence post in the other family's style, a former vice chairman of the safety board who had spent the first meeting telling everyone that the review's job was the record, not a culprit, and that anyone who needed a culprit would find the proceedings disappointing. Diane sat at the table with her hands folded in a way that was not the Ellery distance but an older thing, a church thing. Walter Keneally had driven down from Shreveport with his son's widow's daughter driving, a granddaughter Scott had not known existed, and he sat across the table with his canvas jacket folded on the chair beside him as if it were a small animal that had accompanied him a long way and was resting. The associate opened a redweld folder. "Exhibit 4," she said. "Memorandum, dispatch objection, entered in the system of the company on April 9, 1998, at 19:42 Central, by R. Ellery, dispatcher, New Orleans to Houston, Flight 117."
Scott had prepared, insofar as a man can prepare to hear his dead father's voice after twenty-eight years. He had told himself it would be bureaucratic. He had told himself the preparation was the same as armor. The associate read the memo in the flat professional tone of a person reading minutes, and it was bureaucratic, exactly, gloriously, because bureaucracy was his father's native language, and the voice came through the forms of it the way a man's handwriting comes through a form filled out in a hurry. "I object to the release of Flight 117 as amended," the associate read. "The release was prepared for Ship 214 and a weather picture as of 17:05. The aircraft has been changed to Ship 309. Ship 309 carries an open discrepancy on the weather radar, intermittent, deferred, not resolved to my satisfaction. In addition, the convective line for which the original release allowed has moved east faster than forecast and in my judgment will be across the route within the departure window now proposed. I have advised the captain of my objection. I request that Flight 117 be held until the radar discrepancy is resolved or a serviceable aircraft is substituted, or until the line has passed the route. I understand the station is under pressure on the departure banks. I am entering this objection in writing so that the record of this office shows what was known and when. R. Ellery, 19:42." She stopped. The air conditioning went on with its work. Scott was aware of the conference table's grain in a degree of detail he would remember for years, and of his mother's hand, which had come to rest at some point flat on the table beside his, not near it, on it this time, the distance closed without ceremony by a woman reading the past's only honest minute over her husband's grave.
Nineteen forty-two. The revised departure, the one on the substituted airplane, had pushed at 21:52; the hold that the official report would later erase from the timeline ran two hours and ten minutes, and somewhere in the middle of it a dispatcher had sat down at a terminal and written his name under an objection in the company's own system, and the system, being a system, had kept it, and the company, being a company, had sealed it in a courthouse rather than answer it. Scott's first thought, ignoble and immediate, was arithmetic: that his father had filed the objection two hours and ten minutes before the departure, that a man cannot release an airplane recklessly and also file the only paper in the building begging that it be stopped, that the two facts had been sitting in separate files for twenty-eight years like two men in separate cells each convicted of the other's crime. His second thought was about Patrick Keneally, and it arrived carrying the first one's weight in the other family's colors: that at the same end of that same hold, a thirty-three-year-old captain had also asked, twice, for delay, and the record had arranged them facing each other across the crash like duelists, when in fact they had been standing shoulder to shoulder, the only two men in the system pointing at the same weather and saying stop. And his third thought, which he kept to himself in the lawyer's office and for some time after, was the simplest and the hardest: that the memo's last sentence had been written, deliberately, by a man who knew his family might someday stand in a room like this one. I am entering this objection in writing so that the record of this office shows what was known and when. Robert Ellery had written to the future. He had written to Scott specifically, Scott believed, the way you believe a thing about your father once you finally can, without evidence and without doubt.