Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

What happened over the next six weeks happened the way real institutional things happen, which is to say mostly in rooms Scott was not in, and he learned of it in the order that letters and telephone calls reached a grounded captain's apartment. The Keneally petition was filed in the federal court where the seal had been made a quarter century before, and it asked, narrowly, for the file to be opened to an external review panel under continuing seal as to everything except the panel's findings. Diane's counsel joined it with a one-page filing that Scott read at his kitchen counter standing up: the widow of Robert Ellery, for herself and as executrix, consented to the unsealing and waived, as to the review, every confidentiality provision of the 2000 settlement. His mother had signed away the treaty's enforcement in a single paragraph, and had done it before Scott asked her to, and had told him afterward on the telephone in the flat voice, which now sounded different to him, like a tool being set down: "I kept it while it was protecting children. The children are forty-five and forty-two. It can go and protect the truth for a while and see how it likes the work." The company's answer, when it came, was the genuine surprise of the season, and it arrived in the form of a two-paragraph press statement that Scott read three times for the trap he was certain it contained. Carroway Airlines would not oppose the petition. Further, the chairman, Edward Carroway III, had authorized the commission of an independent external review of the operational record of Flight 117, to be chaired by a former vice chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board, with access to all company archives; the company's internal files would be preserved under litigation hold as of that date. Scott searched the statement for the trap and found, instead, only what Castellano had said in his office, scaled up to the size of an institution: process. It was possible, he thought, reading it a fourth time, that the building had decided at last to be frightened of the record in the right direction.

The chairman's reasons, insofar as Scott ever learned them, were as unglamorous as the rest of the truth in this story, and they suited it. Edward Carroway III was seventy years old, a grandson of the founder, and in April of 1998 he had been the company's vice president of operations, a title which sounded, in the podcast's telling, like a hand on the throttle of that night. It had not been. He had been in Dallas at a bankers' dinner when the airplane went down; he had signed nothing that night and for two weeks afterward had signed only condolence letters and a retention bonus for the crisis counsel. He had read the accident report when it came out with the relief of a man handed a story in which the machinery had failed in human, blamable, terminable units, and he had believed it, wholly and without examination, for twenty-eight years, the way you believe the floor of your own house. In the weeks after the podcast began, a junior archivist in his own company, preparing the merger-era records for a digitization vendor, had sent a memorandum up the chain noting a discrepancy between the 1998 operations archive and the consolidated archive of 2003 in the matter of one hull number, and the memorandum had reached the chairman's desk in the same week as the Keneally letter, and Edward Carroway III had sat with the two pieces of paper and understood that he was the last man alive whose name was on the building who could choose whether the building opened the drawer itself or had it opened in public by other people. He chose, the way his grandfather would have, the version where the company held the handle. There was no confession in him to extract, no buried knowledge to confess; the review would find, in due time, that his sin had been the ordinary executive sin of believing the paper he was handed, and he would spend the rest of the story, to his own evident discomfort, trying to pay interest on it with process. The court's order came six weeks after the petition: the file of R.E. v. Carroway Airlines was unsealed to the review, the objection memo and all exhibits to be produced to the panel, the seal otherwise to continue. Scott read the order at his kitchen counter, standing up, the way he had read his mother's filing, and he noticed that his hands were not steady, and that he did not care, and he called Shreveport, where an old man answered on the fourth ring with the patience of paper, and said, "Mr. Keneally. The court has ordered it opened." And Walter Keneally said, after a silence in which a clock could be heard, "Well. Then I had better live a while longer. I find I want to read my son's file and your father's in the same week, and in that order."

News in the same category

Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

45 Part