Howard Brandt was the last of the night's living architects, and he was the hardest to find, not because he hid but because he had been put away by everyone, including himself, in the drawer marked junior. He had been twenty-six years into a career at the safety board in 1998, which is to say he had been the youngest member of the investigative team by a decade and the one who carried the boxes. The team leader had written the report; the senior members had signed their specialties; and Howard Brandt, who had walked the marsh in hip waders with a camera around his neck and had written the first draft of the timeline section from the station's preliminary traffic summary, had gone on to a long gray career of his own, ending as a regional supervisor with a pension and a garden in Maryland, and he had not spoken about Flight 117 in a professional room for twenty years when the review's letter arrived. He asked, by return telephone call, exactly one question: whether the families would be present when he talked. Told that they would be offered the transcript, he said, in the investigator's note, "Then I had better come and say it to the air in the room, because I have been saying it to my garden for thirty years and the garden is tired of being the only witness." He was eighty-four. He traveled to Houston with his grandson driving, and he testified in the same conference room as the memo reading, with the same air conditioning, and he asked to begin at the part nobody had asked him about, which was 2003.
In 2003, Carroway had merged with a smaller carrier, and the safety board's regional office, Brandt's office, had been asked, as a routine courtesy among archivists, to confirm certain records in the companies' consolidated safety archive for a federal filing. Brandt, by then a supervisor, had drawn the Flight 117 file because he had once carried its boxes, and because a supervisor draws the files nobody else wants to certify. The consolidated archive's version of the accident file was cleaner than the file he remembered. The tail number on the summary sheets read 214 throughout. The timeline had lost its evening. He had sat, he testified, with the consolidated file in one hand and his own memory in the other, and he had done the arithmetic that no one had done for five years: he remembered a substitute airplane, because he had photographed its radar in the marsh and because the substitution had been, in the first chaotic days, one of the hundred facts the team had chased and then, finding the weather overwhelming, set aside as incidental. "Incidental," he said, to the room. "We used the word. A broken captain and a bad release were causes; a changed airplane was scenery. And then the report came out with the scenery written as the set, and I told myself the set dressers were the company's problem." In 2003, with the consolidated file under his hand, he had done the thing he had come to Houston to confess, which was not an act but an omission with a date on it. He had telephoned the company archivist of his acquaintance and asked about the tail number, and the archivist had said the word reconciliation, and had said that during the consolidation the archive had been regularized against the insurance and fleet records, which carried 214 as the hull of record, and that the change was clerical. Brandt had accepted this. "I raised it once," he testified. "One telephone call. I was told it was a clerical regularization. I heard myself be relieved. That is the sentence I have brought you, and I am sorry it took thirty years to deliver, but relief is a strong anesthetic, gentlemen, and I had a career, and the file was closed, and the families, I told myself, had suffered enough disturbance. I have thought since that the families might have preferred the disturbance." He stopped. Hutchinson asked, in the driest voice in the building, whether he was describing a decision he had witnessed being made, and Brandt, to his permanent credit in Scott's account of the man, refused the promotion. "No. I am describing a door I did not push. Who was on the other side of it, I never knew, and I will not invent him for you now."