The meeting with Castellano took place on Friday in an office with a window that looked at a hangar, and it went the way Castellano had promised on the phone: process, not punishment, and not comfort either. Scott's statement was on the desk between them, already read, with pencil ticks in the margins that Scott recognized as a reader's, not a judge's. "You wrote it plain," Castellano said. "Plain is a hard country to live in. Now I will tell you your position in it. You are grounded pending the company's review of the incident, which will take as long as it takes. There will be a letter in your file. What there will not be, unless something else comes out of this that is not in your statement, is a termination. I have fired captains for less honesty and kept them for worse conduct; the arithmetic of my job is not arithmetic. You embarrassed this company in a cabin full of telephones, and the passenger declined to make it a story, and that mercy is his, not yours, and I suggest you spend the grounding remembering the difference." He let that sit. He was fifty-eight, a former check airman with the eyes of a man who read gages for a living, and he watched Scott receive it the way a pilot watches another pilot fly an approach, for the handling. Then he closed the folder. "Now. The other matter, which is not in my lane and which I am nonetheless going to mention once. The company received a letter yesterday from a firm in Shreveport representing the Keneally family. It is not a demand. It asks whether the company would oppose a petition to unseal the 1999 civil file for the purpose of an external historical review. I am told letters are also going out from your mother's counsel, which suggests a coordination I will not speculate about." He turned a pencil over once on the desk. "What do you know about that, Captain?"
"That I went home and asked my mother a question," Scott said. "And that the answer was in a kitchen drawer." He did not say more; the discipline of the week had taught him the difference between plain and complete. Castellano nodded, once, the way he might have noted a fuel figure. "Then I will give you one piece of advice that I would deny giving you. Do not be this company's spokesman, do not be its detective, and do not be its supplicant. Be a witness. Witnesses answer questions and go home. The minute you start carrying this thing on your back through the building, it becomes about a captain with a grievance, and the men upstairs are very good at filing grievances away in drawers. Answer questions. Go home." He stood, which ended it. At the door Scott said, "Is the company going to oppose the petition?" and Castellano said, "That is above both of us, but I will tell you what I told the man who called me from the legal floor. I said the last captain this company grounded over that name was the one who wrote his objection in the log in 1998, so perhaps the building has had enough practice." He did not smile. Scott could not tell, walking out, whether he had been warned or blessed, and decided on the walk to the elevator that it had been both, in the proportions of the building they both worked in.