Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Walter, when the reading had moved on to exhibits of lesser voltage, to pleadings and affidavits and the lawyers' own sediment, leaned once toward the associate during a pause and asked, with the courtesy of a man interrupting a librarian, whether the memo's time was the one on the system clock or the one on the wall. The associate checked with counsel; counsel found the authentication page; the system clock, audited. "Thank you," Walter said, and sat back, and Scott saw the old man's face do something at last with its small economy, some expression that in a younger man would have been triumph, and in him was merely the settling of a board into a frame he had cut for it twenty-eight years before. Afterward, in the corridor, with the granddaughter gone to bring the car, Walter stood with Scott by the elevators while Diane spoke with Hutchinson in the doorway, and he said, "Your father wrote like a man nailing something to a door." "He was a dispatcher," Scott said. "It was the only door he had." "Patrick wrote in his logbook the same night," Walter said. "Different door. I will show you when you come up to the house. It is time you read the other family's paper, Captain, now that your own has started talking." The elevator came. The old man got in alone with his jacket over his arm, and the doors closed on him standing the way he had stood in the cabin, patient in a public place, and Scott turned back to the conference room where his mother was shaking the former vice chairman's hand with the air of a woman concluding a transaction she had waited twenty-eight years to conclude, and he thought that the record had begun, at last, to be frightened, exactly as she had ordered, and that being frightened suited it poorly and well.

Lillian Cho was found by a letter, which was fitting, because everything that rescued the record of Flight 117 turned out to have been kept by people who did not trust computers to remember. The review, having authenticated the objection memo, turned to the question the memo raised and could not answer: what had the night's operations traffic actually said, hour by hour, in the hours the official timeline compressed? The company's archive produced the consolidated record, smooth as a poured floor. The pre-merger archive, what survived of it, produced gaps with finding-aid numbers, the archivist's equivalent of a shrug. It was Scott, answering questions as Castellano had instructed, witness and not detective, who heard himself mention in a deposition session that his father had always said the station traffic that night had run on the teletype until late, because the New Orleans station agent had complained for years afterward, at retiree functions Robert Ellery attended and Diane reported, that her hands had hurt for a week from that night's typing. Hutchinson looked up from his notes with the mildness of a man whose trap has just been walked into by the truth. "The station agent's name," he said. Scott knew it the way he knew all the furniture of the story he had never examined: from his father's mouth, at a table, in the treaty years. "Cho," he said. "Lillian Cho. She worked the New Orleans station. She retired to Slidell, I think. She sent my mother a card when my father died." The review's investigator wrote it down. The union's retired-members office wrote the letter. And Lillian Cho, eighty-five years old, telephoned the review's office herself, collect in spirit if not in fact, and told the investigator she would be home on Thursday and that they should send someone who was not in a hurry, because what she had was in a chest and chests took time.

News in the same category

Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake

45 Part