There was one more document in the sealed file that Scott did not hear read aloud in the conference room, because the review's procedures had saved it, at Diane's written request, for the family alone: Robert Ellery's deposition, taken over two days in the autumn of 1999, three hundred and eleven pages of questions and answers in which a fired dispatcher of fifty-one, in a borrowed suit of a cut his son recognized from church photographs, told the company's lawyers what had happened on the night of April 9 in the flattest prose ever committed to a transcript. Scott read it in the lawyer's office in February, alone, in the room with the view of nothing, with the associate checking on him at intervals with water he did not drink. The deposition was not a revelation; the memo had been the revelation, and the carbons, and the metal. The deposition was something rarer in Scott's experience of his father, which was duration: his father at length, unsealed, in the record, answering. He answered the weather questions like a man reading instruments aloud. He answered the substitution questions with the names of the men he had spoken to, all of whom had since died or scattered, and declined, three times in the transcript, in language the court reporter rendered without emphasis, to agree that their answers had been orders. He was asked whether he had released the flight. "I prepared the release for one airplane and one weather picture," the transcript said. "When the airplane and the picture changed, I objected to the release in writing and asked that the flight be held. The flight departed on the authority of system operations. If the word release is to have the meaning it had in my office, then I did not release that flight. I stopped it, and the stopping is in the log, and the log is the company's, and the company has it." He was asked why he had not done more. The transcript recorded a pause, which the reporter had marked in the era's notation, and then: "I have asked myself that in the small hours for a year and a half. I was a dispatcher. My authority ended at the objection. I filed it in the system in writing, where objections live. I telephoned the station and the duty officer. I told the captain's dispatcher line. What more existed was to stand in front of the airplane, and I have come to believe, sir, that the question you are asking is why I did not prevent the accident, and the answer is that preventing it was not a power my office had, and the men who had the power have not been asked to sit in this chair." He was asked about the settlement that would come the following spring, in the speculative way lawyers ask about the future, and whether he would accept confidentiality as a term, and Robert Ellery's answer was the one Scott read standing up without having decided to stand. "I will accept any term that feeds my family. I have a boy reading that report at my kitchen table like it is sums, and a girl being told things at school, and a wife who asks me to stop saying it at the table. I am not a monument, sir. I am a man with a mortgage. But understand what I am telling you in this room, because I will not be able to tell it outside it. The record is wrong, and I know it is wrong in my own handwriting, and if your seal holds for fifty years the record will still be wrong on the day it opens, and it will open. Paper does that. It waits better than people do."
Airline Captain Challenged an Elderly First-Class Passenger—Then He Realized His Mistake
Chapter 34
Theme:
Font Size:
24px