"When?"
The analyst checked. They could hear the clicking of keys on the other end, the pause while a record was pulled up.
"Seven months ago."
Carter wrote the date in the margin of the report. She wrote it twice, once in numbers and once in words, as if writing it twice would make it more solid. Seven months ago. The tablet had been destroyed seven months ago, and yet yesterday it had been used to search the restricted Professional Standards index.
"Who certified destruction?"
A pause. Longer this time. The analyst was reading, not guessing.
"Officer Walsh."
Brooks closed her eyes briefly. It was not a dramatic gesture. It was a small, private one, the kind a person made when a piece of information was too clean to be a coincidence and too damaging to be ignored. She opened her eyes again and looked down at the table.
Carter asked the next question in the same even tone.
"Who approved the destruction list?"
Another pause. The analyst's voice, when it came back, was quieter.
"Deputy Chief Hale's office."
When the call ended, nobody spoke for several seconds.
The silence was not empty. It was full of the things they were not yet saying. Reed sat with his hands folded. Brooks stared at the access log. Carter set the phone down gently and folded her hands over the tablet report, as if to keep it from sliding away.
Reed finally said it.
"Now we have a conspiracy."
Carter shook her head. It was a small movement, but it was firm.
"We have a tablet."
"We have a supposedly destroyed tablet being used to search your investigation."
"Yes."
"By Walsh."
"Under his account."
Reed stared at her. He was not angry. He was frustrated in the way that came from watching someone he respected refuse to take the step he thought was obvious.
"You're still leaving room."
"I leave room until evidence closes it."
Brooks looked at the access log. She traced one line with her finger, following the time stamp from the previous day, 11:43 a.m., to the credential, to the device.
"What if somebody else has his credential?"
"Then we find that person."
"And if he has the tablet?"
"Then we ask why."
Reed crossed his arms. He leaned back in his chair and looked at Carter directly.
"Director, with respect, how much more do you need before we pick him up?"
Carter looked at him. She did not answer immediately. She let the question sit, because the answer mattered and she wanted it to be precise.
"For what?"
"Tampering."
"We have suspicious access."
"Unauthorized Professional Standards access."
"Administrative violation."
"A destroyed tablet."
"Missing property."
"He certified it."
"Yes."
Reed's frustration showed now, in the set of his shoulders and the way his voice dropped lower, more urgent.
"He's not going to sit there and wait for us to build the perfect case."
"No," Carter said. "He's going to move."
Brooks understood first. She looked up from the log, her eyes moving from Carter to Reed and back to Carter, and the understanding settled on her face before she spoke.
"You want him to."
Carter looked toward her.
"Yes."
Reed stood. He pushed his chair back and stood in one motion, as if he could no longer sit with the idea.
"You're using the administrative review as pressure."
"I'm letting him believe we're focused on him."
"We are focused on him."
"Not only him."
Carter closed the tablet report. She did it slowly, folding the cover over the pages, and set her hand on top of it. The gesture was final, but not dismissive. She was closing one piece of paper so she could look at the larger shape of the case.
"If Hale is involved, Walsh is useful as long as Hale thinks Walsh is the only exposure."
Reed paced once toward the wall. He took three steps, turned, and took three steps back. It was the only pacing he allowed himself. He stopped at the edge of the table.
"That assumes Walsh reports upward."
"If he does."
"And if he runs?"
"Then he tells us what he fears."
Brooks looked down at the photocopied evidence sheet bearing her forged initials. It was on the table beside her legal pad, the copy slightly crooked, the initials in the corner dark and clear. She had looked at them a dozen times since yesterday, and each time they looked less like her handwriting and more like a performance of it.
"What if he destroys something else?"
Carter's expression changed. That was the harder question. It was the one she had been turning over since four in the morning, in the dark, before she came to this room. She did not pretend it was easy. She did not pretend the risk was small.
"We restrict every access point we know."
"We don't know every access point."
"No."
Brooks looked at her. Her voice was steady, but her eyes were not.
"Then this is a risk."
"Yes."
The answer was immediate. Carter never softened risk by renaming it. She did not call it a calculated exposure, or a controlled variable, or an acceptable trade. She called it a risk, because that was what it was, and the people in the room needed to hear it named plainly.
Brooks appreciated that. She hated it too. She appreciated it because it meant Carter would not lie to her about what they were doing. She hated it because it meant there was no version of this plan in which someone did not get hurt, or something did not get lost, and the only choice was which risk to take and who would carry it.
She wrote the word down on her legal pad. Risk. She underlined it once.
Carter looked at the timeline again. The colored tabs. The six cases. The dates that now included a retired tablet, a destroyed tablet, a transfer approved two days after a retirement, an audit closed three days after it was requested. She did not speak for a while. Reed sat down again. Brooks capped her pen and uncapped it. The room settled into a waiting quiet, the kind that came before a phone call or a knock on a door, when everyone knew something was about to happen and no one knew what it would be.