He Threw the Wrong Woman’s Casebook on the Floor—Then One Word From His Lieutenant Revealed Why Major Crimes Had Been Waiting for Her

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Walsh had glimpsed this before Carter closed the cover in the squad room. He had seen the first internal tab, and he had seen enough of the page beneath it to narrow his eyes, and the narrowing had been the reaction of a man who had recognized his own name in a place where he had not expected to find it. He had not read the whole list. He had not needed to read the whole list. He had seen the first name, and he had seen the name beneath it, and the sight had stayed with him as Carter closed the cover and as Reed stepped toward her and as Brooks was asked to follow them into the conference room.

Brooks read the list again. She read it more slowly the second time, and she let each name settle, and she tried to understand what the names had in common, and what the order meant, and why her own name was on the page, and why Walsh's name was at the top. She did not speak while she read. She did not look up at Carter. She did not look at Reed. She kept her eyes on the page, and the page kept its names in the same order, and the order did not change when she read it the second time.

"What exactly are you investigating?" she asked.

Carter looked at Reed. The look was brief, and it was not a request for permission. It was an acknowledgment that Reed already knew the answer, and that he had known it before Brooks had been brought into the room, and that his presence in the room was not accidental. Reed's expression was rigid. His jaw was set, and his shoulders were square, and his hands were folded on the table in front of him, and the rigidity was not the rigidity of a man who was surprised. It was the rigidity of a man who had been carrying a piece of information for a while and who had been waiting for the moment when it would be spoken out loud in a room where it could no longer be left unsaid.

Carter answered.

"Case integrity."

Brooks sat back. The movement was small, and it was controlled, and it was the movement of a detective who had heard a phrase that could mean almost anything and who understood that the breadth of the phrase was itself part of the message. She let her hands rest on the table, and she let her shoulders settle against the back of the chair, and she kept her eyes on Carter.

"That covers a lot."

"It does."

Carter opened the casebook to a flagged section. The flag was a small tab, plain and unmarked, and it marked a place deeper in the casebook, past the list, past the first pages, into the material that had been gathered and sorted and set aside for this conversation. She turned the pages with care, and the pages made a soft sound as they moved, and then she stopped at the flagged section, and she let the casebook lie open on the table between them.

"Over the last fourteen months, six felony cases originating from this division have developed the same problem."

Reed spoke quietly. His voice was lower than it had been in the squad room, and it was steady, and it carried the weight of a man who had reviewed the same material and had come to the same conclusion, and who did not need to raise his voice to make the conclusion sound serious.

"Evidence handling."

Carter nodded. The nod was brief, and it was not a gesture of agreement alone. It was a confirmation that Reed had named the problem correctly, and that the problem had a shape, and that the shape had been seen more than once.

"More specifically, evidence that appears properly logged in the first forty-eight hours and then changes in ways that are difficult to explain."

Brooks frowned. The frown was not a frown of confusion alone. It was a frown of recognition, the frown of a detective who had worked cases where the record had seemed right at the start and had then, weeks or months later, seemed wrong in a way she could not quite place. She had seen files where the details did not line up, and she had seen reports where a date or a time or a signature seemed slightly out of place, and she had learned to note those moments without drawing conclusions from them too quickly. Now she was being told that those moments had a pattern, and that the pattern had repeated itself six times, and that the repetition was the problem.

"Changes how?"

Carter slid a photocopied chain-of-custody record across the table. The paper moved smoothly across the surface, and it stopped in front of Brooks, and the copy was clear enough that the handwriting and the printed entries and the corrections were all visible. Brooks read it. She read it the way she had read the list, slowly and carefully, and she followed each line from the top to the bottom, and she noted the times and the names and the signatures, and then she stopped at one entry that had been corrected. The correction was not large, and it was not messy, and it did not look like the kind of correction that was made in a hurry. It looked like a correction that had been made with care, in a hand that was steady, and the initials beside the correction were hers.

She looked up. The movement was quick, and it was involuntary, and it carried a question she had not yet spoken out loud. She looked at Carter, and then at Reed, and then back at the page, and the initials stayed where they were, beside the correction, in a hand that looked like hers but was not hers.

"I didn't write that."

News in the same category

He Threw the Wrong Woman’s Casebook on the Floor—Then One Word From His Lieutenant Revealed Why Major Crimes Had Been Waiting for Her

45 Part