He Threw the Wrong Woman’s Casebook on the Floor—Then One Word From His Lieutenant Revealed Why Major Crimes Had Been Waiting for Her

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then she picked up the phone. She picked it up with a steadiness she did not entirely feel, with the deliberate calm of a director who had just watched her investigation widen beyond the boundaries she had set for it, and who knew that the only way forward was to go back to the man who saw it first.

"Get me Nolan's current number."

Captain James Nolan answered on the fourth ring. His voice was older than Carter remembered from their first interview six weeks earlier. It was not only the sound of age, or of a man who had been out of the building long enough for the building to forget the particular rhythm of his step in the corridor. It was thinner, as if something had been taken out of it and not replaced, and it carried the careful, measured quality of a man who had learned to weigh every word before he let it leave the house. The line hummed faintly behind him. Somewhere in the background there was the low, ordinary sound of a television turned down too low to make out, and the distant clink of something in a kitchen, the small domestic noises that make the silence that followed feel heavier than it should.

"Hello?"

"Captain Nolan, this is Evelyn Carter."

Silence. Then, "Director."

It was not a greeting. It was an acknowledgment, and a boundary drawn in a single word. He did not ask how she was. He did not ask why she was calling. He waited, and in that waiting Carter could hear the whole of their first conversation again, the conference room with its blinds half-drawn, the coffee gone cold between them, the way he had answered her questions with the precision of a man who had spent a career giving answered that could not be used against him, and the way he had looked at the door more than once, as if checking that it was still closed.

"I need to speak with you."

"We already did."

"Yes."

"And I told you everything I knew."

"No," Carter said. "You told me everything you were willing to say."

The silence changed. It was no longer the silence of a man waiting for a caller to state her business. It became a different kind of silence, denser, more alert, the silence of a man who had just understood that the conversation he thought was finished had in fact only been paused. Carter could hear him breathing, slow and controlled, and she imagined him standing in a hallway or a living room, the phone pressed to his ear, his free hand perhaps resting on the back of a chair, his eyes fixed on nothing in particular while his mind ran through everything he said six weeks ago and everything he did not say.

Nolan's next words were careful. "I don't know what you mean."

Carter looked at Reed. Reed was watching her, his notebook open on his knee, his pen still. Brooks was standing near the desk, her arms folded, her face unreadable. The black casebook was on the desk between them, closed now, its cover dull in the office light. The photograph of the empty evidence envelope was beside it. Carter kept her voice level, the way she had learned to keep it when a conversation was about to turn and she did not want to be the one who turned it too hard.

"Derek Walsh is missing."

Another pause. This one longer. It stretched past politeness, past the ordinary beat of a phone call, into a space where Carter could hear Nolan thinking, where she could hear him deciding what the words meant and what they might cost him to answer. When he spoke again, his voice had lost some of its carefulness. It was quieter, and underneath the quiet there was something raw.

"Is he hurt?"

"I don't know."

"Did Hale find him?"

Carter said nothing. She did not need to say anything. The question itself was the answer Nolan did not mean to give, and the moment it left his mouth he understood what he had done. She heard it in the sharp intake of breath, in the way the line seemed to go very still, as if he had stopped breathing altogether for a second and was listening to his own words came back to him.

Nolan inhales sharply. He understood his mistake. He had just named the one man Carter had not named, and he had named him not as a superior officer or a colleague, but as a threat, as someone who might find a missing man first and do something with that finding that would not be found in any manual.

Carter's voice remained calm. "I need you to come in."

"No."

"Captain—"

"I said no."

The refusal was flat and final, spoken without anger, which made it harder to argue with than anger would have been. It was the refusal of a man who had already made this decision many times before, in the quiet of his own house, and who was not going to unmake it because a voice on the phone asked him to.

"This is no longer an internal audit question."

"It never was."

"Then help me prove that."

Nolan laughed once without humor. It was a short, dry sound, almost a cough, and it carried no warmth at all. "You think proof changes things."

"Yes."

"You still believe that?"

"I have to."

"No. You choose to."

Carter accepted the hit. She did not argue with it, because there was nothing to argue with. It was true, and she knew it was true, and the fact that it was true was the reason she was still sitting at this desk with a missing officer and a forged signature and a drive that might or might not exist. She let the words settle, let them do their work, and then she moved forward anyway, because moving forward was the only thing she knew how to do with a truth like that.

News in the same category

He Threw the Wrong Woman’s Casebook on the Floor—Then One Word From His Lieutenant Revealed Why Major Crimes Had Been Waiting for Her

45 Part