He had just confirmed knowledge of specific alterations. Not a general awareness that something was wrong. Not a rumor he had heard in the squad room. Specific alterations, plural, in specific cases, that he should not have known about in that form unless he had seen them, or made them, or been told about them by someone who had.
The hesitation lasted only a second or two, but in the room it felt longer. Carter could hear Walsh thinking, could hear him realizing what he had said and trying to find a way back from it.
Walsh recovered. His voice came back, a little faster now, a little less controlled.
"The ones you mentioned yesterday."
"I didn't describe any changes."
Silence.
Carter waited. She did not fill the silence. She did not prompt him. She let him sit in it, because the silence was doing more work than any question she could ask.
Walsh's breathing was faintly audible through the speaker. It was shallow, uneven, the breathing of a man who was trying to stay calm and not quite succeeding. Brooks could hear it too. She glanced at Reed, who was watching Carter, waiting for her cue.
Then Walsh said, "I want counsel."
"That's your right."
"And I want to make a statement."
"You can do that with counsel present."
Another silence. Longer this time. Carter could picture him on the other end of the line, perhaps in his car, perhaps in his kitchen, holding the phone too tightly, looking at a wall and trying to decide what to say next. She did not rush him. She had time. He did not.
"Today."
Carter looked at Reed. Reed gave a slight shake of his head, almost imperceptible. Today was too soon. Today would be a mistake, for Walsh and for them. A statement made today, without counsel, without preparation, would be a statement they could not trust and he could not take back.
"Have your attorney contact Professional Standards."
Walsh's voice hardened. The measured tone cracked, and underneath it was something sharper, more desperate.
"You're making a mistake."
"Then help me correct it."
"You don't understand what happened."
"Tell me."
"I can't over the phone."
"Then don't."
"You think I did this for money?"
Carter did not answer. She let the question hang in the air, unanswered, because any answer would have given him something to argue against. She did not think he had done it for money. She did not think he had done it for any single reason yet. She did not know. That was the point. She was not going to tell him what she thought before she knew what the evidence would support.
Walsh continued too quickly. The words came out in a rush now, as if he had been holding them back and they had finally broken through.
"I didn't take anything."
Nobody in the room moved. Brooks stopped breathing for a moment. Reed's eyes narrowed. Carter remained perfectly still, her hand resting on the table, her gaze fixed on the phone.
Nobody had accused Walsh of taking anything. Not yesterday. Not today. Not in the administrative review. Not in the access logs. Not in Nolan's audit request. The six cases were about changes, about classifications, about initials and credentials and timing. No property had been reported missing. No money had been mentioned. No one had said the word theft, or taking, or stealing, in any form.
Walsh had just introduced it himself.
Carter's voice became very quiet. It was not soft. It was not gentle. It was quiet in the way a room went quiet before something broke, the kind of quiet that made everyone in it listen harder.
"I didn't ask if you did."
The line went dead.
The click of the disconnect was sharp in the quiet room. For a moment, no one spoke. The phone sat on the table, its screen darkening, the speaker silent. The morning light still came through the blinds in thin strips. The coffee was still cold. The timeline was still stretched across the table.
Reed stared at the phone. He did not move to pick it up. He stared at it as if it might ring again, as if Walsh might call back and explain what he had just said.
Brooks whispered, "He's scared."
Carter nodded. It was not a judgment. It was an observation, made the way she made all her observations, plainly and without embellishment. Fear was a fact. It could be used, or it could be misleading, but it was a fact in the room now, and it changed the shape of what came next.
"Now."
Reed looked at her. His voice was low, careful.
"Now what?"
"Now we stop pushing."
He frowned. He had expected the opposite. He had expected her to say they should move faster now, that they should bring Walsh in, that they should press while he was frightened and off balance. Stopping felt wrong. Stopping felt like letting him go.
"Why?"
"Because he just told us something important."
"That he's involved?"
"No."
Carter looked at the forged initials again. The photocopied evidence sheet was still on the table beside Brooks's legal pad, the initials dark in the corner, her name written by someone else's hand. She looked at them for a long moment, as if they might tell her something new now that Walsh had spoken.
"He thinks involvement can be explained."
The attorney called at 11:32.
Evelyn Carter took the call standing at the narrow window of her office, the late-morning light falling thin across the casebook on her desk. She had been waiting for it since Walsh left the interview room the day before, his demand for counsel still hanging in the air between the questions he had not answered and the knowledge he had let slip at 9:17. She listened without interrupting while the attorney introduced himself in the measured, unhurried cadence of a man who billed by the hour and knew the value of sounding calm. He did not argue. He did not ask what the inquiry concerned. He asked only for a time, and Carter gave him one, the following morning, early enough to suggest that Professional Standards did not intend to wait, late enough to be reasonable on the record.