The phone rang once. Carter looked at it. Reed looked at it. Brooks looked at it. Carter picked it up.
"Carter," she said.
Her voice was level. She did not ask who it was. She did not need to. She knew.
Walsh's voice was low. Lower than it was in the interview room. Lower than it was on the 9:17 call. It was the voice of a man who was trying not to be overheard, or trying not to be recognised, or trying to keep himself steady.
"I need to talk," he said.
Carter did not hesitate. "Where are you?"
"I'm safe," Walsh said.
"That wasn't my question," Carter said.
"I can't tell you yet," Walsh said.
"You missed your interview," Carter said.
"I know," Walsh said.
"Your attorney is looking for you," Carter said.
"I know," Walsh said.
"You left an evidence envelope in your apartment," Carter said.
Silence. The silence stretched, longer than the silences before it. Carter could hear Walsh breathing on the other end, slow, controlled, as if he was counting his breaths.
Walsh spoke more quietly. "You went inside?"
"A welfare check was conducted," Carter said.
"Did they take it?" Walsh asked.
"Yes," Carter said.
He breathed out. It was not a sigh of relief, exactly. It was something closer to release, as if a weight he had been carrying had just shifted, as if he had left the envelope there on purpose, as if he had wanted it to be found.
"Good," Walsh said.
Carter looked at Reed and pointed toward the recorder. He activates it. The small red light came on. The recorder began to turn, capturing the call, capturing Walsh's voice, capturing everything that followed. Carter did not tell Walsh that she was recording. She did not need to. The call was on her department-issued line, in the course of an active inquiry, and the recorder was standard procedure. She would tell him later, if she needed to. For now, she needed him to keep talking.
"Derek," Carter said, using his first name for the first time, "listen carefully. If you are in danger, tell me."
"I'm not," Walsh said.
"If someone has threatened you—" Carter said.
"No," Walsh said.
"Then come in," Carter said.
"I can't," Walsh said.
"Why?" Carter asked.
"Because you're watching the wrong people," Walsh said.
Carter's eyes narrow. She did not raise her voice. She did not change her tone. But her eyes narrow, and Reed saw it, and Brooks saw it, and Walsh, even over the phone, seemed to sense it, because his next words came more slowly.
"Who should I be watching?" Carter asked.
No answer. The line was quiet except for breathing. Carter waited. She had learned to wait through silence, to let silence do the work that questions couldn't do.
"Derek," she said.
"You think I changed evidence," Walsh said.
It was not a question. It was a statement, flat and tired, as if he had been carrying it for a long time and was finally setting it down.
"You have not been charged with anything," Carter said.
"That means you don't have enough," Walsh said.
"That means I'm not discussing evidence over the phone," Carter said.
He gave a dry laugh. It was a short laugh, without humour, the kind of laugh a man gave when he was too tired to argue and too aware to pretend.
"You really don't waste words," Walsh said.
"No," Carter said.
"That thing yesterday. The desk," Walsh said.
Carter glanced at Brooks. Brooks looked back, her expression unreadable. The desk. Yesterday. The interview room. The moment Walsh had leaned across the desk, his voice raised, his frustration visible. Carter remembered it clearly. She remembered the way Reed had stiffened, the way Brooks had gone still, the way Walsh had caught himself a second too late.
"What about it?" Carter asked.
"I was an ass," Walsh said.
"Yes," Carter said.
Walsh went quiet. It was not the response he expected. Carter could tell by the pause, by the way his breathing changed, by the small, surprised sound he made before he spoke again. He had expected her to soften it, to say it was understandable, to say the stress of the inquiry explained it. She did none of those things. She agreed with him, plainly, and left it there.
"I thought you'd enjoy hearing that," Walsh said.
"I already knew," Carter said.
Despite everything, Reed almost smiled. It was a small movement, barely a smile, a tightening at the corner of his mouth that he suppresses almost immediately. Brooks did not smile. She was watching Carter, watching the way Carter was handling Walsh, the way she was keeping him talking without giving him anything in return.
Walsh did not. His next words came differently. The tone shifted. The tiredness remained, but something else entered it, something closer to resolve, or to fear, or to both.
"I didn't start this," Walsh said.
Carter stood very still. She did not move. She did not look at Reed or Brooks. She kept her eyes on the phone, on the recorder, on the casebook, as if stillness might keep Walsh on the line.
"Start what?" Carter asked.
"You know," Walsh said.
"I need you to say it," Carter said.
"I can't," Walsh said.
"You can," Carter said.
"No. Because the second I do, it becomes real," Walsh said.
Carter's tone remained level. "It is already real."
A long silence. Carter let it stretch. She could hear Walsh breathing, could hear the faint sound of something in the background, a car passing, a door closing, nothing that told her where he was. She waited.
Then Walsh said, "Captain Nolan found the duplicate access."
Brooks looked sharply at Carter. Her head turned, her eyes widen. Duplicate access. The words were new, but the concept was not. Carter had been thinking about access since the tablet, since the search of her investigation, since the moment she realised that someone had used a supposedly destroyed device to look at her work.
"What duplicate access?" Carter asked.
"The credentials," Walsh said.