HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second public meeting was different from the first. The first had been about fear and information. The second, held a month later, was about accountability and next steps. Dr. Okafor reported that most wells had now cleared, that the homes closest to the flow path were still on bottled water pending a second round of tests, and that long-term monitoring would continue for six months. He thanked residents for their patience, and he thanked me, by name, for reporting promptly and for preserving samples. I did not expect thanks, and I accepted it with a nod, because it was not praise I needed. It was confirmation that the order — report, test, inform — had worked.

Karen Holt reported that the state's enforcement referral was complete, and that Vivian and Dale faced separate proceedings: Dale for the application violation, Vivian for authorizing and funding an unlawful application to water she did not own, and for violating the recorded agreement. She did not predict outcomes, but she said the record was "substantial," which in agency language is a strong word. The room, which had been fearful a month before, was now angry in a focused way — not at me, not at the agencies, but at the fact that their own president had put them at risk to improve a view.

Vivian was not at the second meeting. Her lawyer sent a letter, read aloud by a board member, stating that Vivian denied intentional wrongdoing, that she had acted to address algae, and that she would cooperate with the process. The letter was met with silence, not shouting, which is worse for a politician than shouting. Silence means people have stopped arguing and started deciding. After the letter, the board president pro tem — a man named Harold Finch, who had been vice president and who had quietly opposed Vivian's dock citations for months — announced that the board would hold a special meeting to consider Vivian's removal, and that residents would be invited to comment.

I did not attend the board's special meeting as a participant. I attended as an observer, sitting in the back, because it was a Willow Creek Estates internal matter, and I was not a member. I listened while residents spoke, one by one, not about me or my dock, but about their water, their children, their trust. Priya, the young mother, spoke, her voice steady now, saying she had used bottled water for her baby's formula for a month because of a decision she had not been consulted on. Marla spoke, saying she had known me as a neighbor for years and had never seen me act against the community. An older man spoke, saying he had bought his house for the view, too, but that a view was not worth a poisoned well. One by one, they dismantled Vivian's story, not with accusations, but with their own experience.

The board voted, that night, to remove Vivian Blackwater as president, effective immediately, and to suspend her board membership pending the outcome of the state proceedings. The vote was not unanimous, but it was decisive. Harold Finch became interim president. He announced, in his first statement, that the association would cooperate fully with the state, would fund well testing for any resident who requested it, would restore the lake in coordination with me and the state, and would apologize to residents for the failure of oversight that had allowed a single president to act alone. It was a good statement, plain and responsible, and I respected it, even though an apology from the board could not undo the fish kill.

Restoration did not begin with restocking. It began with waiting, testing, and cleaning what could be cleaned. The state, with Ellis's help, mapped the sediment copper levels, and found that the highest concentrations were near the cove where Dale had applied the product, and that they were declining slowly as water flowed and as natural processes bound the copper. The recommendation was: no restocking until copper in water and sediment fell below safe thresholds for two consecutive tests, no chemical "cleanup" that would stir sediment and make things worse, and continued monitoring of dissolved oxygen, pH, and algae. In other words, let the lake heal at its own pace, with help but without hurry.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part