HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

There was a day, in the middle of the investigation, when I almost broke my own rule. A neighbor forwarded me a post from a community group in which Vivian, or someone writing for her, had suggested that I had staged the fish kill, or exaggerated it, to gain leverage over the HOA. The post was vague, deniable, and infuriating, and my first impulse was to reply, with photographs, with the invoice, with everything, in that group, that night. I typed a reply, long and angry, and then I deleted it, and I called Paul instead. Paul listened, and then he said, "If you reply tonight, you will win the argument in that group and lose credibility with the hearing officer, because the hearing officer will see a man fighting online, not a man keeping a record. If you wait, and you let the lab and the invoice speak in the proper forum, you will win where it matters." I waited. It was one of the hardest waits of the case, harder than waiting for lab results, because it required me to let a falsehood sit, unanswered, in public, while I trusted a slower process to correct it. The process did correct it, in the state report, in the board's report, in the restitution order, all of which were public and all of which outlasted the post, which was deleted within weeks. That experience taught me that restraint is not passivity. Restraint, timed correctly, is a strategy, and it is often the only strategy that preserves a record's authority.

I also learned, during that period, to separate my identity from the case in a healthier way. I began to take a morning walk that was not to the dock, but through the woods behind my house, where there was no lake, no fish, no case, just trees and birds and my own breathing. Those walks did not solve anything, but they reminded me that I was a person beyond the case, with a life beyond the lake, and that a life beyond the case is what makes it possible to sustain a case without being consumed by it. My father, I think, would have approved of those walks, because he believed a man should have a place to think that is not his workbench. My mother would have approved, too, because she believed a woman — and a man — should not let a fight become their whole life, or the fight will win even if the case is won.

My own thread, through all of this, has been the thread of a man learning to use cold anger well. Hot anger, I have learned, wants an enemy and a moment. Cold anger wants a record and a repair. Hot anger shouts at a president. Cold anger files an invoice. Hot anger breaks a dock light in retaliation. Cold anger photographs a dock light, logs it, and lets the record show who kept the rules and who did not. I have not always succeeded in staying cold. There were mornings, early on, when I wanted to shout, when I wanted to drive to the ridge and demand an answer, when I wanted to post the check copy online and watch the neighborhood react. Each time, I went back to my notebook, to my father's lesson about labeling, to my mother's lesson about files, to Paul's advice about order, and I waited. Waiting, I learned, is not weakness. Waiting, with evidence accumulating, is strength.

There were also mornings when cold anger felt like numbness, when counting fish felt like a way of not feeling grief, and I worried that I had turned Bertha into a case number. On those mornings, I would go to her stone under the cypress, sit for a while, and let myself feel the grief plainly, without turning it into a task. Grief, I learned, needs its own time, separate from work, or it will leak into work and distort it. I gave grief its mornings, and work its afternoons, and both were honored by the separation. That is, I think, the most personal lesson of this story: that a man can grieve and investigate at the same time, if he does not confuse the two, and if he lets each have its proper place.

My solar work helped with that separation, too, because a roof job is not about grief. It is about panels, inverters, meters, and a customer who needs power. Doing that work well, day after day, reminded me that I was not only a man with a dead fish and a lawsuit. I was also a retired electrician who still installed solar panels when somebody needed a reliable hand, and that identity, ordinary and useful, kept me from becoming only the man from the lake case. I needed that ordinariness, the way a lake needs ordinary days after a disaster, to prove that life continues, not just as recovery but as routine.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part