Only then did I start calling. First the county environmental health office, then the state. I gave them facts, not theories: location, size of kill, species, water color, odor, time discovered, samples taken and held cold, photographs and video available. I asked what lab they used, how they wanted samples delivered, and whether they wanted me to leave the scene undisturbed. The woman on the phone was professional and tired in the way people are who take these calls often. She told me to keep the samples cold, not to add anything, to keep my notes, and that an inspector would come. She gave me a case reference number, and I wrote it in the notebook in block letters and circled it twice.
Second, I called my neighbor on the far side of the cove, a man named Ellis Grant, who is seventy-eight and used to be a county water engineer before he retired to fish and argue about maps. I did not call him to gossip. I called him because if anyone in this valley knew how water moved underground, it was Ellis, and because I trusted his eyes. I told him what I had, short and plain, and asked him to come look before the light changed. He said he would be there in twenty minutes, and he was there in fifteen.
Ellis stood on the dock a long time without speaking. He looked at the water, at the fish, at Bertha on her towel. He knelt and smelled the sample jar I held out, carefully, the way a chemist does, wafting, not inhaling deep. He said one word: "Copper." Then he said, "Or something with copper in it. That metallic bite. Algaecide, probably. Heavy dose." He did not say it as a guess to impress me. He said it as a man naming a familiar smell, and then he immediately corrected himself. "But that's just a nose, not a lab. Get it tested. Don't let anyone tell you a nose is a verdict."
That distinction stayed with me all through what came next. A nose is not a verdict. A suspicion is not evidence. A dead fish is a fact, but the reason it died has to be proved, paper by paper, test by test. I wrote Ellis's words down, with his name and the time, and I noted that he had said "probably" and "not a lab." That honesty would matter later, when other people tried to make the story simpler than it was.
My father died when I was in my thirties, of a heart that had worked hard all his life and then stopped without much warning. I think about him whenever I work with my hands, because he taught me that a job done right is a kind of respect, and a job done sloppy is a kind of lie. He could wire a house so clean you could read the runs like sentences. He taught me to label everything, to test before you energize, to never trust a wire just because somebody told you it was dead. That lesson has saved my life more than once on roofs, and it saved this case, too, in a different way.
My mother, after he died, was cheated by contractors. Not in a dramatic, movie way. In the ordinary, grinding way that hurts most: a roof job priced twice, materials swapped for cheaper ones, a man who took a deposit and vanished, another who did half the work and billed for all of it. She was a proud woman, and she did not want to make a fuss, and the men knew it. I was young then, and angry in the hot way, and I wanted to go to their offices and shout. My mother stopped me, not because she did not want justice, but because she knew shouting would not get her roof fixed. Paper would. We went through her contracts line by line, her receipts, her photographs of the work, the dates the men came and did not come. We took it to a lawyer who did not charge much because he liked my father. In the end she got some of her money back, not all, and a roof that finally did not leak. I learned that anger, if you let it cool and organize itself, can become a file folder. A file folder can do what a fist cannot.