HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The paragraph did not make me king of all the groundwater in North Carolina, as I would sometimes angrily imagine in my worst moments. I want to be clear about that, because exaggeration would have ruined my credibility later. What it did was specific and modest, and therefore enforceable: it described rights connected to the spring on our land, and to the underground system that carried water from the spring through the valley, and it referenced an agreement — dated the same year, 1952 — between my grandfather and the developers who were then laying out the first plots of what would become Willow Creek Estates. That agreement, neglected for decades, described a shared water system: the spring fed the lake, the lake fed an underground flow, and that flow fed wells. The wells, in the modern development, served the homes of Willow Creek Estates. The number, in the current records, was 847 homes.

I sat in that records room for a long time, reading and rereading, with Mrs. Albright bringing me more files without being asked, because she understood what I was finding. The agreement had not been enforced in years. It had not been repealed, either. It had simply been forgotten, filed away while houses were built and boards changed and presidents came and went. It was still there, still recorded, still legally alive in the way old agreements can be alive if no one has formally ended them.

I copied everything, paid for certified copies, and put them in a new folder, separate from the fish kill file and the HOA letters file, labeled in my plain hand: DEED AND WATER SYSTEM — 1952. I drove home slow, thinking about what it meant. If Vivian had put something in my lake, she had not just put it in my lake. She had put it in a system that fed 847 homes' wells. That changed everything. A private disaster, a fight between one stubborn landowner and one powerful association, was about to become a public one, whether anyone wanted it to or not. And the association that had tried to drive me away would now have to tell its own residents what was in their water.

I did not celebrate that thought. It was not a victory. It was a responsibility, and it frightened me more than the dead fish had, because now other people's health was in the record, not just my grief. I went home, put the copies in the fireproof box, and called Paul Danner, my lawyer, and told him what I had found. He was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "Good. Now we do this exactly right, and we tell the health department before we tell anyone else." That was the right order. I agreed, and I have never regretted agreeing.

The health department's first visit to my house was not a formal inspection but a conversation, and I remember it because Dr. Okafor came himself, not an assistant, and he sat at my kitchen table, drank coffee, and asked me to walk him through the deed paragraph in my own words, not in legal language. I did, slowly, pointing to the words "spring" and "underground water system" and "agreement," and explaining what my grandfather had told my father, and what my father had told me, about how the spring fed the lake and the lake fed the wells. Dr. Okafor listened, took notes, and then he asked a question I had not expected: "What do you want for the residents?" I paused, because I had been thinking about what I wanted for the lake, and for justice, but I had not yet framed what I wanted for 847 households I did not know personally. I said, finally, "I want them to know, from tests, not rumors, whether their water is safe, and I want them to have a plan to keep it safe, even after this case is over." Dr. Okafor wrote that down, word for word, and he said, "That's a good answer. We'll build the testing plan around that." That conversation, more than any meeting, shaped the health response, because it put residents, not the dispute, at the center.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part