HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Dale's fine, by contrast, was smaller and was paid in full, promptly, and his license suspension was served without complaint. He later told Paul's office that the suspension had cost him work, but that the training had gained him work, because clients who learned he had completed authorization training trusted him more, not less. That paradox — that admitting a mistake and learning from it can increase trust — is one I have seen in my own electrical work: a contractor who admits a wiring error and fixes it properly is trusted more afterward than one who denies it and is later found out. Dale, by admitting and learning, regained a measure of trust. Vivian, by denying and minimizing, did not, at least not in the time I followed her case. That difference, I think, is not about the size of the mistake. It is about the response to it.

Winter came to the valley, and the lake went quiet in the way lakes do in winter: still, cold, reflective, with cypress knees standing in shallow water and mist in the mornings. I kept testing, though less frequently, as the state advised, and I kept photographing, though the light was lower and the angles changed. The well monitoring continued, and by December, all but two homes had cleared on two consecutive tests; those two, closest to the original flow path, were told to continue bottled water and to expect clearance in the spring, when flow increased and dilution helped. Dr. Okafor called me personally to tell me, because he knew I carried the worry for those families even though it was not my legal responsibility. "You did the right thing reporting early," he said. "Early reporting is why this did not become worse." I thanked him, and I thought about how many disasters are made worse not by the first act, but by the delay in naming it.

The board, under Harold Finch, adopted new rules that winter: no president could authorize spending over $500 without a board vote recorded in minutes; no treatment of any water, common or private, could be authorized without a water test, a written permission from the owner if the water was private, and a label-compliant application plan filed with the board; and an annual audit of all discretionary accounts would be published to residents. Those rules, dry as they sounded, were the real reform. They did not mention Vivian by name, but they were written to prevent the next Vivian, whoever she might be, from acting alone. I attended the meeting where they were adopted, as an observer, and I voted for nothing, because I was not a member, but I nodded when Harold read them aloud, because they were sensible, specific, and enforceable — the same qualities that had made the 1952 agreement hold.

Vivian's formal outcome arrived in January, in a written decision that Paul read to me over the phone, paragraph by paragraph, because I wanted to hear it exactly, not summarized. The hearing officer found that Vivian had authorized and funded an unlawful application of an industrial-strength copper-based algaecide to private water without testing, permission, or board approval; that the application had caused the fish kill and had introduced copper into a water system connected to residential wells; that she had violated state water quality and pesticide rules; and that she had violated the recorded 1952 agreement. The order imposed a substantial state fine, restitution for restoration and well-testing costs, and a compliance order barring her from authorizing water treatments in the county without proper authority. It also referred the matter to the county for consideration of additional penalties, and it noted her removal from the HOA board as a separate, association action.

I listened to Paul read, and I felt not triumph but relief, the kind of relief a man feels when a circuit that has been arcing finally trips cleanly and the house goes quiet. It was proportionate. It was lawful. It was based on paper, not on my anger. Vivian would pay, not ruinously, but significantly; she would not be president again; she would not be able to do this again without facing a compliance order; and the lake's restoration would be funded, in part, by restitution, not solely by my pocket or by residents who had done nothing wrong. That was justice as I understood it: not vengeance, but a record, a fine, a removal, and a repair.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part