HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The Hendersons' well had cleared, and they had a framed copy of their test result on their refrigerator, next to their grandchildren's drawings. I saw it when I went inside to check the panel monitor, and I thought about how a lab result on a refrigerator is a strange kind of decoration, but also a honest one: it says, we tested, we know, we are watching. That is what a community that has been frightened needs: not reassurance, but evidence, posted where you can see it every morning while you get milk for coffee.

Vivian's appeal, when it came, was brief and unsuccessful. Her lawyer argued that the fine was excessive, that she had acted in good faith, and that the board's removal had already punished her enough. The hearing officer, in a supplemental decision, upheld the fine and the restitution, noting that good faith does not excuse an unlawful application to water one does not own, and that the board's action and the state's action were separate, serving different purposes: one governed association membership, the other governed environmental law. Paul read me the decision, and I filed it, and I did not celebrate. Appeals are a right, and exercising a right is not wrongdoing. What mattered was that the record held on appeal, as it had held at the hearing, because it was built on invoices, labs, and agreements, not on rhetoric.

During the appeal period, Vivian listed her house for sale. I learned this not from gossip but from a real estate sign on the ridge, visible from my dock on a clear day. I do not know if she sold it, or if she stayed, or if she moved to another neighborhood to start again. I do not know if she ever understood, fully, what she had done. I hope, for the sake of whoever lives next to her next, that she learned to ask whose water it is before she treats it. I do not follow her life now. My life is the lake, the wells, the neighbors who stayed, and the work of watching water clear.

The sale sign, when I saw it, stirred a complicated feeling: relief that the immediate pressure was gone, sadness that a neighborhood had lost a president in this way, and a quiet resolve not to let the next president, whoever it is, repeat the pattern. Harold's rules, if they hold, will help. The monitoring plan, if it is followed, will help. But rules and plans only help if people read them, and reading is a habit, not a law. I have tried, in my small way, to encourage that habit: by sharing my notebooks when asked, by explaining the deed in plain language, by answering questions on roofs and porches without making people feel foolish for not knowing. Knowledge, I have learned, is not just a file. It is a practice, repeated, until it becomes character.

The summer after the appeal, the lake reached a milestone the state had set: three consecutive months of water tests below copper thresholds, dissolved oxygen normal, and a healthy diversity of small fish observed. Ana Reyes came for a survey, wading with a net, counting species, and she found bluegill, catfish, crappie, and several young bass, all healthy, all active. She also found dragonfly larvae in the reeds, which she said was a good indicator of improving water quality, because larvae are sensitive to copper. I photographed her survey, not to prove anything, but to remember it, because a survey is a kind of census, and a census of a recovering lake is worth keeping.

Ana also told me something I had not known: that Big Bertha's scar, pale beneath her lower jaw, was likely from a time when she was young and had been caught and released, or had escaped a predator, and that scars like that are common in long-lived bass, and that they are, in a way, a record, too — a record of survival. I liked that thought: Bertha carried her own record, on her own body, the way I carry mine in notebooks. She had survived, for years, until a human decision she could not survive. That is the difference between natural scars and unnatural kills: one is part of living, the other is an interruption of living.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part