HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When my turn came, I testified for two hours, with breaks, and I told the story in order: the morning, the fish, the photographs, the samples, the chain of custody, the letters, the deed, the agreement, the health department notification. I did not raise my voice. I did not call Vivian a poisoner. I said, "The person responsible, as I learned beyond any reasonable doubt from the invoice, the account record, the contractor's statement, and the lab results, was Vivian Blackwater, president of the Willow Creek Estates homeowners association." I said it because Paul had told me that, in a formal proceeding, with the record before the officer, naming the person the record named was not gossip. It was testimony. I said it, and then I went back to facts: dates, numbers, photographs.

Vivian's lawyer cross-examined me, politely but firmly. He asked if I had ever been angry at Vivian, if I had ever wanted revenge for the letters, if I had ever exaggerated the fish kill. I answered honestly: yes, I had been angry; no, I had not sought revenge, and my record showed I had not retaliated; no, I had not exaggerated, and the photographs and the state's own count supported more than two hundred dead fish. He asked if I claimed to own all the groundwater in North Carolina. I said no, clearly, and I quoted my own disclaimer: the deed did not make me king of groundwater, it gave me specific rights connected to the spring and the system, and those rights had been violated. The hearing officer wrote that down, and I saw her nod, almost imperceptibly, at the modesty of the claim.

Vivian herself did not testify that day. Her lawyer said she would submit a written statement, which she did, a week later, reiterating good faith, reliance on the contractor, and belief that the lake was HOA property. The statement did not include a board vote, a permission letter, or a water test. It included an apology, of a kind: "I regret the loss of fish and the concern to residents." It was not an apology to me, by name, and it did not admit the payment was improper. It was, I thought, the apology of a person who still believed her intentions should outweigh her paperwork. Intentions, I have learned, do not clean a lake. Paperwork, testing, and permission do.

The hearing officer took the matter under advisement, which is the formal way of saying she would think and write. Paul told me not to expect a quick decision, and not to discuss the hearing in the neighborhood beyond what was already public. I obeyed, and I went back to the lake, which did not care about hearings and which continued, slowly, to clear. The heron returned one morning in late autumn, stood on the far bank, and this time it hunted: a quick strike, a small fish — a survivor bluegill, quick and wary — swallowed, and then the heron stood still again, as if confirming that the water was, once more, a place where hunting was possible. I photographed it, and I wrote in my notebook: "Heron hunting again. First time since the kill." That entry felt like a small, earned hope, not a victory, but a sign.

The restitution payments, when they began, arrived not as a lump sum but as scheduled payments tied to specific costs: first, well testing; second, state monitoring; third, restocking; fourth, shoreline work. Paul explained that scheduled restitution is harder to evade than a single payment, because each installment is tied to a receipt, and a missed installment triggers a compliance review. I tracked each payment in my notebook, with dates and amounts, not out of suspicion but out of habit: a man who tracks samples tracks payments, too. Each payment, when it arrived in the association's account for restoration, was reported to residents in Harold's newsletter, with the cost it covered, so residents could see, month by month, that the money was going to the lake and the wells, not to lawyers or to general funds. That transparency, again, was the point: restitution that is visible is restitution that rebuilds trust, while restitution that is hidden, even if paid in full, leaves residents wondering.

News in the same category

HOA Poisoned My Lake to Prevent Me From Fishing — Didn’t Know Their Water Supply Depends on It

45 Part