Some of the women pictured had lost children. Some had lost husbands, parents, jobs, teeth, houses, entire countries in which they had been girls. We could have made any number of exhibitions out of loss and left people thinking they had understood an entire life. The woman with the bicycle wheel rather put a spoke in that, if you'll forgive me. You had to account for the possibility that she was counting the minutes until she could get back on her bike and go tearing round the far side of the racecourse, knowing just how fast a woman could travel with the wind not quite behind her and a pair of tyres recently attended to by somebody who loved her.
The yellow dress was on the seventh slide. It had large pockets. The woman who wore it could have been Bea March going to a dance after work. Her baby was tiny, red, very much alive, reaching towards the lens with one wrinkled starfish hand.
We turned the projector off and let Bea take her grandmother outside. I don't know what they said. The account Bea wrote afterwards said simply that they had seen what they came for.
In the box marked INEZ AND JO we found slides underneath the mirror. Two women in swimming costumes sitting on the edge of an empty pool. Two women on a bicycle. Two women in different chairs with the same baby. On the mount of the last one somebody had written a date and a question.
Did we do all right?
My sister leaned across my chair and pressed two fingers gently to the wall, over the place where the baby's face had been.
The Unkindest Photograph
A photograph can contain the truth and still tell a lousy story. This is what I learned on Wednesday afternoon when an online newspaper printed a picture of Mara with her arm raised as though to strike my sister. Actually a spider had landed in Nell's hair. Mara, having been married into our family for seven years, knew that my sister would prefer the temporary loss of her dignity to the company of any creature with more than four legs.
The caption said POLICE INVESTIGATE FAMILY ROW. A policeman did indeed come into the room. He wanted to know whether an illegally parked bicycle belonged to any of us.
By then we had all turned off our telephones. Such a luxury, switching off. It makes you feel you have walked out of the world with a single flick of the thumb. At the end of the school day, when I put mine back on, there were eleven calls from Miss Drew.
Kit was perfectly safe. She had taken the attendance register and erased her own name. Then she had gone through a display of good work and removed the labels from her pictures. She had gathered the scraps into an envelope and given them to her teacher for safekeeping.
βKit says people have been using her name without asking,β Miss Drew said. βI think she has a point. It is making it hard to take the register though.β
I collected my daughter from school. On the way home I asked what we should call her.
βKit,β she said, surprised I had to ask.
βThen how will they know you're you?β
βThey can ask me.β
I had my own bad photograph. It showed me carrying Kit outside the registry office when she was about six months old, Mara having gone inside to witness a friend's wedding. In the picture I am holding a yelling baby by the back of her dress. People have asked if I hadn't quite mastered the trick of supporting a child with two arms. What you can't see is my other hand with two fingers secured round a little plastic ring she'd tried to eat. Ten seconds after the picture was taken the ring was on the pavement and she was pulling on my nose to see whether she could get an equally satisfying noise out of her father.
I used to keep the picture pinned above the workbench. An all purpose corrective to the temptation to assume things were what they looked like. After Mara was gone I threw it face down in a drawer because I thought it made me look terribly young and because there was a flash of her green hat in the registrar's window. It embarrassed me to feel worse about the flash of green than about the fairly straightforward slander being done to my parenting.