"Molly loves you," Cora said quietly, and she had not meant to speak at all, but the words came out before she could stop them, and all three of them turned to look at her, and she kept her voice low and steady, because Ella was listening, even if Ella could not understand the words, and because Molly was listening too. "Molly loves you, Mrs. Merrick. She is your daughter. Nothing I do changes that. I have never tried to take her from you. I have only ever tried to look after her."
Astrid looked at her, and for a second something flickered in her face, something that might have been shame, or grief, or recognition, and then it was gone, and her mouth tightened, and she turned back to Rupert. "You see?" she said, and her voice was sharp again. "You see how she does it? How reasonable she is? How perfect she is? She is always so reasonable, so perfect, so calm, and I am always the one shouting, always the one who looks unreasonable, always the one who looks like the bad mother. Well, I am not going to stand here and be judged by my own maid and my own daughter and my own husband in my own drawing room. I did not hurt Ella. I did not sabotage anything. The stroller was old. The bolt was worn. It was an accident, and if you cannot see that, then you are choosing to believe a child's shaky video over your own wife."
"I am choosing to believe what I saw," Rupert said, and he was shouting again now, and his face was inches from hers, and they stood face to face in the middle of the marble room, the fireplace behind Astrid and the television behind Rupert, and the shouting rose and rose until it filled the whole room. "I saw you with a wrench in your hand at nine forty-seven at night. I saw you tell our daughter to keep it a secret. I saw the axle snap halfway down the stairs this morning. I saw Cora fall, Astrid, I saw her fall hard on the marble floor with our baby in that stroller, and I stood in that hall and I blamed her for it, I blamed her and I threatened to sack her and I threatened to call the police on her, and all the time it was you, it was you in the garage the night before, and if Ella had been hurt, if that stroller had tipped all the way over, if Cora had not held on as long as she did, then what, Astrid? Then what would you have said? That it was an old stroller? That it was an accident?"
Astrid opened her mouth to shout back, and then she stopped, and her face went white again, and Cora saw her glance, just once, very quickly, toward the television, toward the black-and-white footage of the staircase, toward the frozen image of the stroller surging forward and Cora falling, and in that glance there was something Cora had not seen in her before, not defiance and not anger, but a flicker of real fear, the fear of a woman who has just understood, properly understood, what she did and how close it came to being so much worse than she had planned.
It was Molly who spoke next, and her voice was so quiet after all the shouting that it seemed to come from a different room entirely, a smaller room, a calmer room, a room where people spoke to each other instead of shouting. She had been standing in front of the television the whole time, watching her parents argue, holding her phone in her hand, and she had not cried, and she had not moved, and now she looked at her mother, and she looked at her father, and she said, in a voice that was barely louder than a whisper, "Mummy never fixes things."
The words stopped the argument dead. Rupert turned toward her. Astrid turned toward her. Cora, by the door, closed her eyes for a second, because she knew what Molly meant, and she knew how much it had cost an eight-year-old to say it out loud in front of both her parents, and she knew that it was the truest thing anyone had said in that room all morning. Molly went on, still quiet, still steady, her eyes fixed on her mother's face. "Mummy never fixes things. When my bike had a flat tyre, Cora fixed it. When the kitchen tap leaked, Cora called the man to fix it. When my school shoe came undone, Cora tied it. Mummy does not fix things. Mummy does not even know where the tools are. So when I saw Mummy in the garage with a wrench, turning the bolt on Ella's stroller, I knew it was not fixing. That is why I filmed it. I filmed it because Mummy never fixes things, and I wanted Daddy to see it, because I knew nobody would believe me if I just told them."