Karl worked slowly. He ran his fingers along the frame of the stroller, checking the joints and the folding mechanism, and then he bent lower and shone his torch on the front axle, where the bolt sat in its housing. He turned the front wheel gently with one hand, feeling for play in the axle, and the wheel wobbled, loose in a way that a stroller wheel should never wobble, and he frowned and reached for his magnifying glass and leaned in closer. He examined the head of the bolt for a long time, turning his torch this way and that so that the light caught the metal from different angles, and then he sat back on his heels and said, in a steady voice, that the bolt had been backed out by hand, with a wrench, and that it had not worked itself loose. He said that the marks on the head of the bolt were fresh, bright metal showing through where the wrench had gripped it, and that the pattern of the marks was consistent with a small adjustable wrench, the kind kept in a household toolkit, and that the bolt had been turned back several full turns, far enough that the axle could shift under load, and that once the stroller was pushed down the stairs, with the weight of the baby and the slope and the movement, the bolt had backed out further until the axle had snapped free. He said that he had serviced this same stroller two weeks earlier, that he had checked the axle himself, that he had torqued the bolt correctly to the manufacturer's specification, that he had recorded the service in his own book, and that a bolt torqued correctly could not back itself out in two weeks of normal use, not on flat floors and pavements and gentle slopes, not in any way that he had seen in thirty years of repairing prams and strollers. He said that someone had loosened it, deliberately, with a tool, and that there was no other explanation that fitted what he was seeing.
Quincy asked him if he was certain, and Karl said that he was certain, and that he would put it in writing, and that he would sign it. Quincy asked him if the stroller had been old or worn out, and Karl said that it had not, that it was a high-end grey stroller, bought when Ella was born, well maintained, the frame sound, the brakes sound, the harness sound, and that apart from the loosened bolt there was nothing wrong with it. Quincy asked him if a morning check by the person pushing it would have caught a bolt that had been loosened in this way, and Karl said that it would not necessarily have caught it, that the bolt sat inside its housing and looked normal from the outside, that the wheel felt firm when the stroller was standing still, and that the looseness only showed itself under load, when the stroller was moving, and that a careful person doing a normal check of the brakes and the axle and the harness would have had no reason to suspect that the bolt had been turned back by hand the night before. He said that Cora's check, as he understood it, was exactly the check a careful person would do, and that it was not a fault in the check that the bolt had failed, but a fault in the bolt having been loosened at all. Rupert closed his eyes for a moment when he heard that, and Cora looked down at Ella, and Molly reached out and took Cora's free hand and held it, and Astrid said nothing at all, her face very still now, her arms still folded, her eyes fixed on the stroller as if she wished it would disappear.
Quincy thanked Karl, and asked him to stay, because there was one more thing he wanted him to look at. He asked Whitlock to bring in the gardening toolkit from the garage, and Whitlock went out through the hallway and came back a few minutes later carrying a small green metal toolbox, the kind kept for garden work, with Astrid's name written on a label on the lid in her own handwriting. Quincy opened it on the marble floor, and inside, among trowels and twine and seed packets and a pair of secateurs, lay a small adjustable wrench, its jaws worn smooth from use, its handle scratched. Karl picked it up, turned it over in his hands, and then bent down again to the stroller and held the wrench against the head of the front axle bolt, fitting the jaws to the marks on the metal. The fit was exact. He said so, plainly, and then he took his magnifying glass and compared the width of the jaws with the width of the fresh marks on the bolt head, and said that the marks matched the wrench, that the size was right, that the pattern of wear on the jaws was consistent with the pattern of the marks, and that in his opinion this was the wrench that had been used to back the bolt out. Talbot photographed the wrench beside the bolt, and the toolbox beside the stroller, and the label with Astrid's name, and Quincy asked Karl to confirm, for the record, that the wrench came from Astrid's gardening toolkit in the garage, and Karl said that he could confirm only that it was the wrench in the toolbox that Whitlock had brought from the garage, and that the toolbox was labelled with Astrid's name, and Quincy nodded and said that that was enough for now, and that the wrench and the toolbox would be taken as evidence, and that they would be examined further. Astrid watched the photographs being taken, and her hands, which had been folded across her chest, dropped to her sides, and she pressed them flat against the gold fabric of her dress, as if she were trying to hold herself still.