"I am listening to you now," Rupert said, and he was shouting again, and the calm was gone, and the two of them stood face to face in the middle of the room, shouting over each other, their voices rising and crashing together, his deep and hers high, his words about the wrench and the bolt and the video, hers about the stroller and the accident and the family, and neither of them was listening to the other at all, and the argument had reached the point where it was no longer about convincing anyone of anything, it was only about being heard, about being louder, about not backing down, and Cora stood by the door with Ella in her arms, holding the baby close, murmuring to her, shielding her small ears as best she could with her hands, and Molly stood in front of the television, still holding her phone, watching her parents shout at each other, her face pale and still, and the marble room rang with their voices, and the fireplace stood cold and empty behind them, and the television showed the staircase, over and over, the stroller surging forward, Cora falling, and it seemed as if the shouting would go on forever, as if it would never stop, as if the whole house would shake apart with it.
And then, underneath the shouting, cutting through it cleanly, came another sound. It was not loud. It was not dramatic. It was the sound of the front doorbell, ringing once, clear and ordinary, in the hall outside the drawing room, and then the sound of a heavy knock, three firm knocks on the front door, and then silence, and then the doorbell again, and Rupert stopped shouting in the middle of a sentence, and Astrid stopped shouting in the middle of a word, and they both turned toward the door, and Molly turned toward the door, and Cora turned toward the door, still holding Ella close against her shoulder, and the four of them stood frozen in the marble drawing room, listening, as the sound came again, the doorbell and the knock, patient and official, from the front of the house, and nobody moved, and nobody spoke, and the police had arrived.
***
The argument was still going when the front door opened. Rupert Merrick and Astrid Merrick stood face to face in the marble room, both shouting, neither listening, their voices bouncing off the polished floor and the tall fireplace and the large television on the wall, where the black-and-white footage of the staircase had frozen on the image of Cora Renshaw falling. Molly Merrick stood a few feet away from them in her light blue T-shirt and wide-leg jeans, holding her phone up in both hands, the screen still lit, the video of her mother in the garage still paused on the image of a small wrench turning a bolt. The baby, Ella Merrick, ten months old and dressed in pink, was asleep at last in Cora's arms on the lower steps, her small face pressed against the grey fabric of Cora's dress, her breathing slow and even after the long crying of the morning. Cora sat very still, one hand cupping the back of Ella's head, the other resting on her own knee, watching Rupert and Astrid without speaking. She had been shouted at already that morning, blamed already, threatened with dismissal and with the police, and now the police were actually here, and she did not know whether that made things better or worse.
Sergeant Clive Whitlock, forty-seven, came in first, walking in from the left through the wide doorway that led from the entrance hall, his dark uniform neat, his boots quiet on the marble despite their weight, his face calm in the way of a man who had walked into many angry rooms and learned not to add his own anger to them. Officer Sadie Talbot, twenty-nine, followed half a step behind him, her dark uniform the same, her notebook already open in her hand, her eyes moving quickly around the room, taking in the television, the phone in the child's hands, the baby, the woman sitting on the steps, and the man and woman shouting at each other in the middle of the floor. Neither officer raised their voice. Whitlock stopped a few paces inside the room and said, in a level tone that cut through the shouting more effectively than any shout could have done, that he was Sergeant Whitlock, that this was Officer Talbot, and that they had come in response to a call from this address. He asked everyone to stop talking for a moment, to step apart, and to tell him, one at a time, what had happened.
Rupert turned toward him, his face flushed, his dark navy shirt damp with sweat at the collar, his hands shaking slightly as he lowered them to his sides. He said that he was Rupert Merrick, that this was his house, that he had made the call himself, and that he wanted the police to look at what his daughter had filmed. Astrid, standing opposite him in her long shimmering gold dress, her blonde hair loose around her shoulders now, her hands still raised from the argument, said that nothing had happened except an accident, that the stroller was old, that the maid had been careless, and that her husband was making a scene over nothing. Her voice was high and fast, and she kept glancing at Molly, and then at the phone, and then away again, as if she could not decide which of them was the greater danger. Whitlock listened to both of them without interrupting, and then he looked at Molly, and his expression changed, softening in a way that his uniform did not soften. He asked her, gently, if she was all right, and Molly nodded, and said that she was all right, and that Ella was all right, and that Cora was hurt but not badly, and that she had something to show the police. Talbot crouched down slightly so that she was closer to Molly's height and said that she would like to see it very much, whenever Molly was ready, and that there was no hurry, and that nobody was in trouble for showing the truth.