“You don't remember the conversation, but you remember enough to tell me his recollection may be wrong?”
Langley's attorney interrupted.
“Miss Carter, my client is answering to the best of his ability.”
Emily turned toward the attorney.
“Then perhaps you can help him understand the question.”
Margaret Lewis raised a hand.
“Let's remain focused.”
She placed another document on the table.
It was the death certificate.
The authorization field contained a signature that did not match the attending physician's signature on other surviving medical records.
A handwriting examiner had determined that the signature was unlikely to have been written by the named physician.
Langley stared at it.
“Have you seen this before?” Margaret Lewis asked.
“I don't know.”
“Who authorized the certificate?”
“I cannot say.”
“Was it standard procedure for an administrator to issue a death certificate without an attending physician's signature?”
“No.”
“Was it standard procedure to transfer a living infant to an adoption agency while listing the parents as unknown, without documenting efforts to identify the family?”
Langley did not answer.
His attorney advised him not to respond.
Eleanor's face had gone pale.
“Someone took my daughter away.”
Langley looked at her.
“I did not take your daughter.”
“You signed the document that transferred her.”
“I signed an emergency placement form based on the information provided to me.”
“And you never checked whether that information was correct?”
Langley looked away.
“I believed the process was being handled appropriately.”
Eleanor shook her head.
“You believed whatever made the paperwork easier.”
Langley stiffened.
“That is an unfair characterization.”
“Then explain the paperwork.”
He had no answer.
The interview ended shortly afterward.
Langley's attorney refused to permit further questioning without reviewing the newly discovered records. The group left with no confession and no clear explanation.
But the documents had established several facts.
The infant had been recorded alive.
A transfer had occurred.
The official paperwork had later listed the child as unidentified.
And the death certificate had been authorized through a process that did not match standard hospital procedure.
On the drive back to Chicago, Eleanor stared out the window.
“He knows more than he told us.”
Emily looked at the documents in her lap.
“Maybe. But we still need proof.”
Eleanor turned toward her.
“You sound like your father.”
Emily looked up.
“Thomas?”
“Yes. David used to say that the most dangerous thing in a room was a person who had already decided what the truth must be.”
She smiled sadly.
“Your father believed that questions were more important than assumptions.”
Emily thought about Thomas's notebook.
“Then we keep asking.”
That evening, Margaret Lewis received an email from the hospital's archive department.
The message contained a list of documents found in the same storage box as Langley's transfer authorization.
One entry was especially significant.
Northbridge Family Services — Emergency Infant Placement Register — October 17–24.
The register had not yet been examined.
If it survived, it might reveal where N-04 had been sent after leaving St. Agnes.
And if the entry could be connected to Emily's adoption, it might finally identify the people who had handled her placement.
For the first time, the investigation had moved beyond conflicting memories.
It had reached a chain of documents.
And somewhere along that chain, someone had made a decision that had changed two families forever.
The Agency That No Longer Existed
Northbridge Family Services had closed its doors fourteen years earlier.
Its building on the north side of Chicago had been sold to a medical billing company. The old sign had disappeared, the reception desk had been removed, and the waiting room where adoptive parents once sat had been converted into offices filled with computers.
The agency's records, according to the state registry, had been transferred to a nonprofit archival organization in Springfield.
But when Margaret Lewis contacted the archive, she learned that only part of Northbridge's collection had arrived.
The adoption files were present.
The financial records were present.
The emergency placement registers were missing.
An inventory listed them as transferred to a private storage company in 2009.
The storage company had since been acquired by another business.
No one could immediately confirm where the boxes had gone.
Emily stared at the inventory during a meeting at the law office.
“Every time we find a record, another one disappears.”
Margaret Lewis shook her head.
“Records are often scattered when institutions close. It does not automatically mean someone deliberately removed them.”
“I know.”
Emily looked at the list.
“But if the documents were transferred, someone should have signed for them.”
“Correct. We will trace the transfer.”
Eleanor sat beside Emily, studying the inventory.
For the past week, the two women had met several times. Their conversations were still awkward, but the awkwardness had begun to soften.
Eleanor had shown Emily photographs of David Whitmore, the house where she had planned to raise her, and the small nursery with blue curtains. Emily had shared stories about Thomas and Margaret Carter, including the summer Thomas taught her to repair a bicycle and the evening Margaret stayed awake with her after a frightening school experience.
They were learning one another through stories.
Not all of those stories were easy.
Eleanor sometimes looked at Emily with such intense longing that Emily felt herself retreating. She could see the years of missed birthdays in her biological mother's expression, and she did not know how to comfort a grief she had not caused but had somehow inherited.
Eleanor, in turn, had begun to understand that Emily's love for Margaret Carter was not an obstacle to their relationship.
It was part of the life Emily had been given.
One afternoon, Eleanor asked whether Emily would like to see the nursery.
Emily agreed.
They walked through the Whitmore house together, past the formal dining room and the staircase where David had once hung holiday decorations. At the end of the upper hallway, Eleanor stopped before a pale wooden door.
“I haven't changed it,” she said.
Emily looked at her.
“Why?”
“I thought that if I changed it, I would be admitting that the room no longer had a purpose.”