May I see your birthmark?

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Why would Dad write to Eleanor?”

“I don't know.”

The envelope was dated six years earlier.

Emily carefully opened it.

Inside was a letter several pages long.

Mrs. Whitmore,

You do not know me, and I hope this letter does not cause you distress. My name is Thomas Carter. My wife and I adopted a daughter named Emily twenty-three years ago through Northbridge Family Services.

I am writing because I believe there may be a connection between our daughter's adoption records and the death of a newborn child at St. Agnes Medical Center.

I have no wish to cause pain to a family that has already suffered. I have also spent years trying to determine whether the documents we received accurately described our daughter's beginnings.

The agency told us that Emily's records were restricted because of the hospital fire. When I asked for the original transfer information, I was told that the matter had been reviewed and that no further information was available.

I recently found an old newspaper report identifying you as a mother whose newborn daughter died during the fire. The article included the date of birth and the name of the hospital.

Our daughter's birth date is the same. Her original identification bracelet contains a temporary number that appears in a surviving hospital record.

I cannot say that your daughter and our daughter are the same child. I have no proof. I can only tell you that the records are inconsistent and that I believe the inconsistency deserves investigation.

If you have already found peace with the loss of your child, I do not wish to disturb it without cause. But if you have ever wondered whether the official account was correct, I would be grateful for the opportunity to share what I have found.

Whatever the answer, please know that Emily is loved. She is a thoughtful, kind young woman, and we are grateful every day that she came into our lives.

I am not writing to claim that she belongs to us more than she belongs to anyone else. I am writing because I believe every person deserves to know the truth about their own history.

If you wish to speak with me, I will make myself available.

Respectfully,

Thomas Carter.

Emily read the letter twice.

Then she lowered it to the table.

“He knew.”

Margaret's eyes filled.

“He suspected.”

“He suspected that Eleanor might be my mother.”

“Yes.”

“Why didn't he send it?”

Margaret looked at the date.

“I think he was afraid of hurting someone. He didn't want to tell a grieving woman that her dead child might be alive unless he could prove it.”

Emily touched the paper.

“That sounds like him.”

“He also worried that if he contacted Eleanor directly, Northbridge might claim he was violating the confidentiality agreement.”

Emily closed her eyes.

Thomas had been caught between two fears.

He feared that the records were wrong.

He also feared that pursuing the truth might harm the family he had built.

So he had written a letter that might have changed everything, then placed it in a briefcase and never sent it.

Emily felt a mixture of sadness and gratitude.

Her father had not stopped caring.

He had simply reached a point where he did not know how to move forward.

Margaret touched her arm.

“I wish he had told us.”

“So do I.”

Emily folded the letter carefully.

“Can I show this to Eleanor?”

“Of course.”

They drove to the Whitmore house together.

Eleanor was reading in the living room when they arrived. She stood as soon as she saw their expressions.

“What's happened?”

Emily sat beside her.

“We found something my father wrote.”

She handed Eleanor the letter.

Eleanor read it slowly.

At the first paragraph, her expression was curious.

By the third, her hands began to tremble.

When she reached the sentence describing Emily as a thoughtful, kind young woman, she stopped reading.

She pressed the paper against her chest.

“He knew about me.”

“He suspected you were my biological mother,” Emily said. “He didn't know for certain.”

Eleanor looked up.

“Why didn't he send it?”

“We think he was afraid of causing pain without proof.”

Eleanor lowered her eyes.

“He was kinder than many people who claimed to be protecting me.”

Margaret sat quietly nearby.

Eleanor continued reading.

When she reached the final paragraph, she began to cry.

“He wanted me to know that you were loved.”

Emily nodded.

“He wanted you to know that I had a good life.”

Eleanor wiped her face.

“I am grateful to him for that.”

She looked at Margaret.

“And to you.”

Margaret shook her head.

“We did what any parents would do.”

“No,” Eleanor replied softly. “You did what parents who loved their child did. You gave her a home, even when you didn't know the whole story.”

Margaret looked down, unable to answer.

The letter changed something between them.

Until then, Thomas had been a presence in the investigation through his notebook, his records, and his unanswered questions.

Now his own words had entered the story.

He had not treated Eleanor as an enemy.

He had not assumed that Emily's biological identity gave him a reason to hide the truth.

He had wanted everyone involved to understand that love and honesty could exist together.

Eleanor folded the letter carefully.

“May I keep a copy?”

“Of course,” Emily said.

“I would like to place it beside David's photograph.”

Emily smiled.

“I think he'd have liked that.”

For the next hour, they talked about Thomas.

Eleanor asked what he had been like as a husband, what made him laugh, and how he had handled difficult decisions.

Margaret told her about his quiet humor, his stubbornness, and his habit of leaving notes around the house whenever he thought someone might need encouragement.

“He once wrote me a note that said, 'The washing machine is making a strange noise. I have decided it is a mechanical problem, not a personal criticism.'”

Eleanor laughed through her tears.

“David would have said exactly that.”

Emily watched them.

The two women were no longer simply comparing their memories of her.

They were discovering the people who had shaped those memories.

Later that evening, Eleanor asked whether Emily would consider using the name Grace as a middle name.

Emily thought about it.

News in the same category

May I see your birthmark?

33 Part