May I see your birthmark?

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

A dead case.

Her father had written those words as though he were quoting someone who had no right to use them.

The next entry was dated February 3.

I found the name of a nurse in an old newspaper article about the fire. Ruth Bell. She was listed among the staff members who assisted with evacuation. I need to find her.

Emily looked at her mother.

“Did Dad ever find her?”

Margaret shook her head.

“Not that he told me.”

The box contained several letters from Northbridge Family Services. Most were formal and impersonal. They referred to Emily as a minor whose records were subject to confidentiality restrictions. One warned that unauthorized attempts to identify her biological relatives could create “unnecessary emotional disturbance.”

Another letter, however, was different.

It had been written by Thomas to the agency's director.

We are not seeking to interfere with any family's privacy. We are asking for an accurate account of our daughter's medical history and the circumstances surrounding her placement. If the records are correct, there should be no reason to refuse us access to the original documentation.

A handwritten response appeared beneath the letter.

Mr. Carter, the matter has been reviewed. Further inquiries will not be productive. Please consider the emotional stability of your household before pursuing this issue.

There was no signature.

Emily stared at it.

“That's not an answer.”

“No,” Margaret said quietly. “It isn't.”

At the bottom of the box, beneath a stack of envelopes, Emily found a small brown packet wrapped in a piece of faded cloth.

Inside was a hospital identification bracelet.

It was yellowed with age. The plastic clasp had cracked, but the printed information remained partly legible.

The name was not Emily Carter.

It read:

INFANT GIRL — W-17

Below the label was a date.

October seventeenth.

And beside it, in faded blue ink, someone had written a second number.

N-04.

Emily turned the bracelet over.

A small paper tag had been folded beneath the clasp. Most of the writing had blurred, but a few words remained visible.

Transfer authorized by R.B.

Emily stared at the initials.

“R.B.”

Margaret leaned forward.

“Ruth Bell?”

“I don't know.”

Emily photographed the bracelet from every angle.

Then she noticed another item beneath the cloth: a small envelope sealed with yellowing tape.

Her father's handwriting appeared across the front.

If I cannot finish this, give it to Emily when she is ready.

Emily felt her throat tighten.

Margaret pressed a hand to her mouth.

“He wrote that?”

“Yes.”

Emily carefully opened the envelope.

Inside was a single letter, dated five years earlier, several months before Thomas's final hospitalization.

My dear Emily,

If you're reading this, I have either found the answers or run out of time trying. I hope it is the first.

Your mother and I have always loved you as our daughter. Nothing you discover about your beginnings can change the life we shared. I need you to remember that before you read anything else.

When you were adopted, I noticed inconsistencies in the paperwork. I was told they were caused by the hospital fire. I wanted to believe that explanation because I did not want to bring fear into our home.

But the more I looked, the more I became convinced that someone had changed the records after the emergency.

I never found proof that you were taken from another family. I never found proof that anyone deliberately harmed you. I only found reasons to ask questions and people who seemed determined to prevent those questions from being answered.

If you decide to investigate, do not assume that everyone who refused to help was part of something terrible. Some may have been afraid. Some may have followed instructions without understanding them. Some may have believed they were protecting a child.

But do not let anyone convince you that your right to know your own history is a threat.

I found the name Ruth Bell. She was a nurse at St. Agnes on the night of the fire. She left the hospital not long afterward. I believe she may have known what happened to you.

I tried to locate her, but the address I found was outdated. If I had more time, I would have continued.

I am sorry I did not tell you sooner. I thought I could protect you by solving this first. Perhaps that was my mistake.

Whatever you discover, you were never a mistake.

You were our daughter every day we were allowed to be your parents.

Love always,

Dad.

Emily could not speak.

She sat on the basement steps with the letter in her hands, tears running silently down her face.

Margaret sat beside her.

For a long time, neither moved.

Then Emily leaned against her mother's shoulder.

“I wish he'd told me.”

“So do I.”

“I could have helped him.”

“Maybe.”

Margaret stroked her hair.

“But your father loved you. He thought he had to carry the fear himself.”

Emily closed her eyes.

She remembered Thomas teaching her to ride a bicycle, standing outside her bedroom after nightmares, and waiting in the school parking lot when she stayed late for debate practice. She remembered him telling her that questions were not dangerous simply because their answers were uncomfortable.

He had spent years trying to follow his own advice.

And he had died without knowing whether he was right.

Emily wiped her face and looked at the notebook again.

“I'm going to find Ruth Bell.”

Margaret nodded.

“I'll help you.”

“Even if the truth is painful?”

“Especially then.”

Emily placed the letter back in its envelope.

For the first time since the dinner at Maison d'Or, her fear had acquired a direction.

The heart-shaped birthmark had connected her to Eleanor Whitmore.

The DNA test would establish whether that connection was biological.

But Thomas's records suggested that the hospital fire had left behind a second mystery: someone had changed an identification number, someone had authorized a transfer, and someone had decided that a family should stop asking questions.

Emily did not know what those actions meant.

She would not accuse anyone without evidence.

But she would no longer accept a closed file as an answer.

Before leaving the basement, she took photographs of every document and carefully packed the originals into a secure folder.

At the top of her list, she wrote three names.

Peter Langley.

Ruth Bell.

Northbridge Family Services.

Then she added a fourth.

Grace Eleanor Whitmore.

She paused before writing it.

If the DNA test confirmed what Eleanor believed, that name might be the one she had been given at birth.

For now, Emily left a space beside it.

The answer was close enough to reach.

News in the same category

May I see your birthmark?

33 Part