“It's late.”
“Please.”
Margaret sighed.
“All right. I'll look tomorrow morning. I'll call you as soon as I find it.”
Emily wanted to insist.
Instead, she said, “Thank you.”
After they hung up, she sat in the dark for a long time.
She had imagined her biological parents as people who had abandoned her, people who had been unable or unwilling to raise her, or perhaps people who had died before she could know them.
She had never imagined a mother who had spent twenty-three years believing her child was dead.
And she had never imagined that the people who had raised her might have been frightened into silence by someone who wanted the truth to remain buried.
At 11:48 p.m., Emily's phone vibrated.
A text message appeared from an unknown number.
Emily, this is Eleanor Whitmore. I am sorry if I frightened you tonight. I will not pressure you. I only ask that you give me the opportunity to discover the truth with you.
A second message arrived moments later.
There is one thing you should know. The hospital fire was officially ruled an accident, but I have never believed that explanation.
Emily stared at the screen.
Then she typed a reply.
I will agree to a DNA test. But I want the truth about what happened, no matter what it says about either of us.
Eleanor responded almost immediately.
So do I.
Emily placed the phone on the table.
Outside, a siren passed somewhere in the distance.
She looked at the heart on her wrist one last time before turning off the light.
For twenty-three years, it had been nothing more than a small mark on her skin.
Now it had become the beginning of a mystery that might change every memory she had of her own life.
And somewhere in a large house in Winnetka, a woman who had buried her daughter without a body was finally allowing herself to imagine that the grave she had carried in her heart might never have belonged to her child at all.
A Test of Blood and Memory
Eleanor did not sleep.
At two in the morning, she sat in her study with the old hospital documents spread across her desk. She had brought them out of a locked cabinet she had not opened in years.
The first folder contained the birth records.
The second contained the hospital's written account of the fire.
The third held the death certificate.
The fourth contained the correspondence that had followed.
She read everything again.
The papers had not changed. The words were the same words she had read hundreds of times over the years. Yet now every sentence seemed to contain a hidden question.
The death certificate listed her daughter's name as Grace Eleanor Whitmore.
The cause of death was recorded as complications arising from smoke exposure during the hospital fire.
But the form contained no identifying physician's signature in the usual place. Instead, a typed note stated that the attending physician had authorized the record because the original medical file had been lost.
Eleanor had noticed the missing signature before.
She had asked about it.
The hospital administrator had explained that emergency conditions sometimes required unusual documentation.
At the time, Eleanor had been too devastated to challenge him.
Now she read the sentence again.
The original medical file had been lost.
Not damaged.
Not partially destroyed.
Lost.
She turned to the next page.
A letter from the hospital's legal department stated that the infant's remains had not been released to the family because the fire had made recovery and identification impossible.
Yet another document, dated two days later, referred to the transfer of the infant's personal effects to the hospital's family services office.
Eleanor frowned.
If no one had recovered the child's remains, how had the hospital confirmed her death so quickly?
She picked up the telephone.
The time was 2:17 a.m.
She called her attorney, Margaret Lewis, who had represented the Whitmore family for nearly thirty years.
Margaret answered with the voice of someone who had been asleep.
“Eleanor? Is something wrong?”
“I need you to look at the original hospital records.”
“Now?”
“Yes.”
“What happened?”
Eleanor explained the encounter at the restaurant, the birthmark, the matching birthday, and Emily's willingness to undergo DNA testing.
By the time she finished, Margaret was fully awake.
“Eleanor, this could be significant. But we need to proceed carefully.”
“I agree.”
“First, we establish whether Emily is biologically related to you. Then we examine the records.”
“I want both investigations to begin immediately.”
“We can arrange a private DNA test through an accredited laboratory. We should also request the original hospital and adoption records.”
“Some of those records were sealed.”
“Then we seek a court order if necessary.”
Eleanor looked at the documents.
“There is something else. I want to know who authorized the death certificate.”
“Do you have the name?”
“Not in the place where it should be.”
Margaret was silent for a moment.
“Send me copies of everything. Don't alter or annotate the originals. I'll arrange for a document examiner to review them.”
Eleanor glanced at the clock.
“How soon can we have a DNA result?”
“Depending on the laboratory, perhaps several days. We can request expedited processing.”
“Do it.”
“Eleanor, I need you to prepare yourself for either result.”
“I have spent twenty-three years preparing myself for the worst.”
“That isn't the same as being prepared for the truth.”
Eleanor looked toward the dark window.
“No,” she said. “It isn't.”
By nine the next morning, arrangements had been made.
Emily agreed to meet Eleanor at Margaret Lewis's law office, where the DNA samples could be collected under controlled conditions. She insisted that her adoptive mother be present.
Eleanor agreed immediately.
When Emily arrived, she wore a simple blue sweater and dark trousers. Her hair was tied back, and her expression was guarded. She looked younger than Eleanor had first realized, though there was a steadiness in her eyes that made her seem older.
Margaret Carter accompanied her.
She was a small woman with silver hair and a careful manner. She carried a worn handbag against her chest and seemed determined not to show how frightened she was.
Eleanor stood when they entered.
For several seconds, the two women looked at each other.
Eleanor wanted to embrace Emily.
She wanted to touch her face, brush the hair from her forehead, and ask whether she had been happy as a child. She wanted to know whether she liked strawberries, whether she had ever broken a bone, whether she had been afraid of the dark, and whether someone had been there to comfort her.
But she had no right to ask those questions as though the relationship had already been established.
“Thank you for coming,” Eleanor said.
Emily nodded.
“Thank you for arranging the test.”
Eleanor turned toward Margaret Carter.
“Mrs. Carter.”