May I see your birthmark?

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The greater question was why anyone had needed her to disappear.

The Daughter Who Was Declared Dead

Eleanor Whitmore did not remember how she left Maison d'Or.

She remembered Emily's face.

She remembered the heart-shaped birthmark.

She remembered the exact moment the young woman's voice had trembled when she said that her birthday was October seventeenth.

Everything else had become a blur.

Richard drove them through the city in silence. The black sedan moved past illuminated storefronts and crowded intersections, but Eleanor barely noticed the route. She sat in the passenger seat with Emily's handwritten phone number pressed between her fingers.

At a red light, Richard glanced at her.

“You need to be rational.”

Eleanor turned toward him.

“Don't tell me what I need.”

“You cannot decide that a stranger is your daughter because of a birthmark.”

“I didn't decide anything. I asked for proof.”

“And if the proof says she isn't?”

“Then I will accept it.”

He looked doubtful.

Eleanor's voice hardened.

“But if the proof says she is, you will explain why you looked frightened when she mentioned the hospital.”

Richard faced the road again.

“I was surprised.”

“No.”

“You are upset.”

“I have been upset for twenty-three years. I know what surprise looks like.”

He tightened his hands around the steering wheel.

The light turned green.

Neither spoke for the rest of the drive.

Their home stood behind iron gates on a quiet street in Winnetka, a large limestone house surrounded by old oak trees and carefully maintained gardens. Eleanor had once loved the house. It had been the place where she and her husband, David Whitmore, planned to raise their children.

David had died eleven years earlier after a sudden cardiac arrest while traveling for work.

Their daughter had supposedly died in infancy.

The house had gradually become a museum of the life Eleanor had failed to keep.

A nursery remained at the end of the second-floor hallway. She had closed the door after the funeral that never felt like a funeral, but she had never changed the room. The pale yellow curtains still hung beside the windows. A rocking chair stood beneath a framed print of a moon and stars. In one corner sat a wooden cradle David had assembled himself, sanding every edge until the wood was smooth enough that it could not scratch a baby's hand.

Eleanor had never been able to give those things away.

She had also never been able to enter the room without imagining a child who had never grown up.

That night, she went straight upstairs.

Richard followed her.

“Eleanor, listen to me.”

She opened the nursery door.

The room smelled faintly of cedar and dust. Moonlight rested on the floorboards.

“I have listened to you for twenty-three years,” she said.

“I have been trying to protect you.”

“From what?”

“From reopening something that nearly destroyed you.”

She turned.

“Do you remember the hospital?”

“Yes.”

“Do you remember the fire?”

“Of course.”

“Do you remember what the doctors told us?”

“They told us the neonatal wing had been evacuated.”

“And then?”

Richard hesitated.

“They said there had been a fatality.”

“They said our daughter was dead.”

“Yes.”

“Did you see her body?”

“No.”

“Did you ask to see her?”

“They explained that the damage made identification impossible.”

Eleanor's expression did not change.

“Who explained it?”

“I don't remember the doctor's name.”

“You were David's closest friend. You were the person who stayed with me when David had to return to work. You attended every meeting. You spoke with the hospital administrator. You handled the paperwork when I could barely stand.”

“I was trying to help.”

“Then help me now.”

She held out Emily's number.

“Find out who this woman is. Find out why she was adopted. Find out who signed the documents. And do not tell me that this is too painful to investigate.”

Richard stared at the paper.

“I can't promise that what we find will be what you want.”

“I am not asking for what I want. I am asking for the truth.”

He accepted the number.

“I'll contact someone tomorrow.”

“No.”

His head lifted.

“Eleanor—”

“Tonight. Call our attorney. Call the hospital. Call anyone you need to call. But I want a DNA test arranged as soon as Emily agrees.”

Richard looked at the number again.

Then he nodded.

“I'll see what I can do.”

Eleanor watched him leave the room.

For several minutes, she remained beside the cradle.

Then she sat in the rocking chair and began to cry.

Not the restrained tears she had shed at charity dinners or the silent tears she had hidden in her bedroom after midnight.

These were the tears of someone whose grief had suddenly acquired a question mark.

If Emily was her daughter, then the child she had mourned had not died in the fire.

She had grown up somewhere else.

She had learned to walk without Eleanor holding her hands. She had spoken her first words without Eleanor hearing them. She had celebrated birthdays without Eleanor making a cake, gone to school without Eleanor waiting at the door, and suffered losses without Eleanor knowing she needed comfort.

There had been twenty-three years of life.

Twenty-three years of ordinary moments Eleanor could never recover.

But beneath that pain was something more frightening.

If Emily had survived, then someone had lied.

And if someone had lied about the death of her child, what else had been hidden?

Across the city, Emily sat at her small kitchen table.

Her apartment was modest, with two bedrooms, a narrow living room, and a kitchen barely large enough for two people to stand comfortably. A stack of textbooks occupied one end of the table. A chipped ceramic mug held pens and pencils. Photographs of her adoptive parents were arranged on a shelf above the sofa.

She had not turned on the television.

She had not changed out of her uniform.

She kept looking at her wrist.

The heart-shaped mark was small enough to disappear beneath a watch. As a child, she had sometimes traced its outline with her finger while listening to her parents tell stories about the day they brought her home.

Margaret had always said that the mark looked like a tiny promise.

Thomas had called it her compass.

“Whatever happens,” he had once told her, “remember that you don't have to know where you came from to decide where you're going.”

News in the same category

May I see your birthmark?

33 Part