May I see your birthmark?

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Her daughter had a photograph of a baby.

And she had never discussed the incident.

That evening, Caroline called back.

She agreed to meet.

The meeting took place at a small café in Evanston.

Caroline was fifty-two, with dark hair and a thoughtful expression. She carried a flat archival box and placed it carefully on the table.

“I don't know what this will prove,” she said.

“Neither do we,” Emily replied.

Caroline opened the box.

Inside were photographs, old letters, and a small diary.

The photograph showed Lydia Shaw standing beside a hospital cot. She was younger than she appeared in the archive image, and her expression was serious.

The baby in the cot was wrapped in a pale blanket.

The left wrist was visible.

The heart-shaped birthmark was unmistakable.

Caroline watched Emily's face.

“My mother wrote a note on the back.”

She turned the photograph over.

In faded handwriting, the note read:

W-17. The child they said had no family.

Emily felt the blood drain from her face.

Eleanor closed her eyes.

Caroline looked between them.

“I don't understand.”

Margaret Lewis explained the situation carefully, beginning with the DNA test and the hospital records. She avoided speculation and described only what had been established.

Caroline listened in silence.

When the explanation ended, she looked at the photograph again.

“My mother was not a cruel person,” she said. “She worked with families for decades. She believed she was helping children.”

“No one is accusing her of anything yet,” Margaret Lewis replied.

“But you think she knew something.”

“We think she was present during an unusual transfer and that her note suggests she knew the child had been described as having no family.”

Caroline rubbed her forehead.

“I remember her waking up at night after the fire. She would go into the kitchen and sit alone for hours. Once, when I was a teenager, I asked whether someone had died. She said, 'A child was lost, and nobody wanted to admit it.'”

Emily stared at her.

“Those were her exact words?”

“Yes.”

“Did she explain what she meant?”

“No. She told me to forget I had asked.”

Caroline opened the diary.

Most entries concerned ordinary matters: work schedules, grocery lists, visits to relatives. But several pages from October and November of the year of the fire had been torn out.

The remaining pages contained brief references to the incident.

October 18: Robert says the matter is settled.

October 21: Peter insists the records must remain consistent.

October 29: I cannot stop thinking about the child.

November 3: I was told that the family had accepted the report. I do not believe that is true.

Emily read the last line twice.

“The family had accepted the report,” she whispered.

Eleanor shook her head.

“I never accepted it. I was told to accept it.”

Caroline looked horrified.

“My mother knew someone was lying.”

Margaret Lewis turned to another page.

The handwriting changed slightly, as though Lydia had written it in a hurry.

If the child ever returns, tell her that the mark was not the only thing I remembered.

Emily looked up.

“What does that mean?”

Caroline stared at the diary.

“I don't know.”

The final surviving entry was dated several months later.

I have kept a copy of the original transfer list. Robert says it no longer exists. He is wrong.

The room fell silent.

Margaret Lewis slowly closed the diary.

“Caroline, do you know where your mother kept her files?”

Caroline thought for a moment.

“She had a storage locker after she retired. I helped her clear it out before she moved into assisted living. There were several boxes we didn't open because they contained old work documents.”

“Where are they now?”

“In a storage unit I still rent. I haven't looked at them in years.”

Emily looked at Eleanor.

The missing register might not have disappeared after all.

It might have been hidden by someone who feared that the truth would never be allowed to survive in the official records.

Caroline agreed to help them search the boxes.

Before leaving the café, Emily looked at the photograph one last time.

She had been a newborn when it was taken.

She could not remember the room, the nurse, or the woman holding the clipboard.

But someone had written a note about her.

Someone had remembered the mark.

And someone had preserved evidence that the official account was incomplete.

For twenty-three years, the truth had survived in fragments.

Now those fragments were beginning to connect.


 The Register in the Locked Box

Caroline Shaw's storage unit was located in a low concrete building outside Evanston.

The hallway smelled of dust and cold metal. Fluorescent lights hummed overhead, and the floor bore faint tire marks from carts used to move furniture.

Caroline unlocked the unit and pulled the door upward.

Inside were cardboard boxes, a small desk, two plastic storage bins, and an old filing cabinet with a rusted handle.

“My mother kept everything,” she said. “She never trusted computers.”

Emily smiled faintly.

“My father was the same way.”

They began with the boxes labeled NORTHBRIDGE.

The first contained training manuals.

The second held personnel records.

The third contained old forms and blank stationery.

The fourth was marked with a date: October 17–24.

Caroline stopped.

“This might be it.”

Margaret Lewis put on gloves before opening the box.

Inside were folders, notebooks, and several envelopes. Most were labeled with infant identification numbers rather than names.

Emily's heart began to pound.

They found W-12.

Then W-15.

Then W-16.

Finally, beneath a folder containing emergency placement guidelines, they found W-17.

News in the same category

May I see your birthmark?

33 Part