POOR COWBOY SAVED A 22-YEAR-OLD APACHE GIRL — THEN THE WHOLE TOWN TURNED AGAINST HIM

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I call the debt a lie, Elias said. "And I have seen the proof of it. I have seen Grady's own figures, in Grady's own hand. The miners' pay is skimmed. The store prices are raised to make debts that never shrink. A dead man is still listed as owing. If any man here doubts me, let him ask why a mine that pays its men fairly needs a fence around its compound and a foreman who counts the women at night."

Tolliver, standing by the door, took a step forward, his scarred knuckles white. Sheriff Calloway put a hand on his arm, and Tolliver stopped, but his eyes stayed on Elias, flat and cold.

Mayor Holt held up both hands, his face pale. "Mr. Crowe, this is not the place for accusations — "

It is exactly the place, said a new voice, gentle and firm, and Pastor Eli Marsh rose from his seat near the front and came to stand beside Elias. The pastor was fifty, gray at the temples, with a face that had never learned to be cruel. He looked out over the congregation, and the room went quiet in a different way, the way a room goes quiet when a man is about to say something true.

I preached on the Good Samaritan last Sunday, Pastor Marsh said, "and some of you were not pleased. I will preach on him again tonight, briefly, because he is the only text that fits this room. A man lay wounded by the side of the road. A priest passed by. A Levite passed by. A Samaritan — a stranger, an outsider, a man the town would have called unclean — stopped, and bound his wounds, and carried him to safety, and paid for his care. Our Lord did not ask the wounded man for his papers. He did not ask whether the wounded man owed a debt. He asked only who had been a neighbor to him. Mr. Crowe was a neighbor. The question before this town tonight is not whether a debt is owed. The question is whether we will be neighbors — or whether we will be the men who passed by on the other side."

The silence that followed was long and full. Then Sam Whitaker stood up, big and quiet, and said, "I stand with Elias." And Dr. Bell stood, and said, "I stand with him too." And Hattie O'Rourke stood, and said, "And I." And Deputy Ben Oakes, young and earnest, standing near the door with his hand on his belt, stood a little straighter, though he said nothing yet.

But not everyone stood. Amos Pike, the storekeeper, sat with his eyes on his hands, and did not move. Half the miners in the back rows stared at the floor. A woman near the front whispered, loud enough for all to hear, "He has brought trouble on us all, and for a foreign woman." And the town, which had come in as one crowd, went out as two — those who walked home with Elias in their hearts, and those who walked home with Grady's words in their ears, and no one, not even the pastor, could say yet which half was larger.

Elias walked home that night with Xiu beside him and Biscuit trotting ahead, and the stars were cold and bright over Main Street, and he felt, for the first time in five years, that he was not running from anything. He had stood in front of the whole town and refused to move. Whatever came next, he had done that, and no one could take it back.

Jeb Carver had been Elias Crowe's friend for ten years.

They had freighted together through summers so hot the wagon grease melted and winters so cold the mules' breath froze on their own whiskers. They had shared camps, and coffee, and the long silence of men who do not need to fill every mile with talk. Jeb had stood at Sarah's funeral, hat in his hands, and had not said a word, because there was no word, and Elias had never forgotten it.

That was why, when Jeb came to the Gilded Spur on the night after the town meeting and found Silas Grady waiting for him in the back room with a bottle and a ledger of his own, Jeb told himself he was only going in to listen.

Grady poured the whiskey himself. He was smooth about it, the way a man is smooth when he has bought other men before and knows the price of each one. "Jeb," he said, "I hear you owe me money."

Jeb's throat went dry. "A hundred and fifty dollars," he said. "From the winter. The mule went lame and I lost the Tucson run."

A hundred and fifty dollars, Grady repeated, as if he were tasting the number. "And I hear you cannot pay it. And I hear the sheriff is not the only man in this town who knows it."

Jeb looked at the floor. The saloon noise came through the wall — glasses, laughter, a piano playing something tired and out of tune. "I'll pay it," he said. "Give me time. Give me till first snow."

Time is what I am offering you, Grady said. He set his glass down, and his soft hands folded on the table, and his hard eyes did not leave Jeb's face. "I don't want your money, Jeb. I want your knowledge. Your friend Elias rode to Red Rock and came back with something that belongs to me. A page from my books. A piece of paper he has no right to. He means to carry it to a territorial official, and make trouble for honest men who employ this town. Tell me where he keeps it, and when he means to move it, and your debt is gone. Forgiven. Wiped clean. A hundred and fifty dollars, gone, for one conversation."

News in the same category

POOR COWBOY SAVED A 22-YEAR-OLD APACHE GIRL — THEN THE WHOLE TOWN TURNED AGAINST HIM

45 Part