The morning after the attack, the cabin smelled of smoke and wet ash, and Biscuit slept by the hearth with his breathing slow and even and his yellow head resting on Xiu's foot, as if he had decided that was his post and no one would move him from it.
Elias stood in the doorway and looked out at the yard. The corral gate hung broken on its hinges. The lean-to roof was blackened where the lantern had burst. The mules stood in the corral with their ears back, Hob planting his feet and watching the road as if he expected trouble to come back down it at any moment. Sam Whitaker was already at work on the gate with a hammer and a length of spare rail, his big hands moving with the steady patience of a man who fixed things because fixing things was what he knew how to do.
We will need a new rail, Sam said, without looking up. "And the lean-to wants a patch before the next rain. I will bring timber from town tomorrow."
You do not have to, Elias said.
I know, Sam said. "I am doing it anyway."
Inside, Xiu was kneeling beside Biscuit, her hand moving in slow circles over his side, feeling the rise and fall of his ribs. She had not slept. Elias could see it in the shadows under her dark eyes, and in the way her black hair had come loose from its tie and fallen forward over her face. She looked up when he came in, and for a moment neither of them spoke. The night was still between them — the shouting, the gunfire, the iron bar raised over the dog — and it needed to be spoken about, or it would sit in the cabin like a third person in the room.
He saved me, Xiu said at last, very quietly. "Biscuit. He ran at Tolliver when Tolliver was bigger, when Tolliver had the iron. He did not think. He only — protected."
He is a brave dog, Elias said.
He is like you, she said, and then she stopped, as if the words had surprised her as much as they had surprised him.
Elias sat down across from her, on the floor by the hearth, so that they were level with each other and with the dog between them. He had been thinking about this conversation since the town meeting, since the night she had nursed his grazed arm and they had talked about Wei and Sarah, about grief and guilt, about the dead who did not leave you simply because they were gone. He had been thinking about it, and he had been afraid of it, because there were things a man could say that could not be taken back, and things a woman could hear that could change everything between them, whether she wanted them to or not.
Xiu, he said, "I need to tell you something plainly, because you deserve plain words. Not hints. Not kindness that means something else."
She watched him, her hands still on Biscuit, her chin lifted the way it always lifted when she was afraid and refusing to show it.
I am not asking you to run, he said. "I am not asking you to hide. And I am not asking you for anything at all. But I have to tell you the truth of it, because it is the truth and you have a right to hear it from me, not to guess at it. I love you."
The words sat in the small cabin like a stone dropped into still water. Outside, Sam's hammer rang against the rail. Inside, the fire crackled, and Biscuit sighed in his sleep, and Xiu did not move.
I loved Sarah, Elias went on, because he would not say this thing halfway, and he would not let Xiu think he had forgotten the woman who had come before her. "I loved her for years, and I grieved her for five, and I thought that part of my life was finished — that I would freight and sleep alone and grow old with a dog and six mules for company, and that would be enough. It was not enough. It was only quiet. And then I found you in the arroyo, and I carried you to the doctor, and I watched you refuse to be pitied, and refuse to be frightened into silence, and refuse to run when running would have been easier — and somewhere in all of that, I stopped running too."
He stopped. His throat was tight. He had never been a man of many words, and he had just spent more of them than he usually spent in a week.
I am not asking you to answer me now, he said. "I am not asking you to answer me ever, if you do not want to. Your life is yours. That is the whole point of all of this — that no man owns you, not Grady, not Tolliver, not me. I only wanted you to know."
Xiu looked down at Biscuit, and then at her own hands, and then back at Elias. Her eyes were shining, but she did not cry. She had cried the night before, over the dog, and now there was something else in her face — a stillness, a weighing, as if she were listening to something inside herself that spoke in a language even she was still learning to translate.