Elias felt it the moment he stepped out of the boarding house with his hat in his hand. The street was the same — dust, coal smoke, horse dung baking in the sun — but the people had sorted themselves as plainly as cattle cut from a herd. Outside Pike's store, three miners stood with their arms folded and watched him pass without a word, their faces closed as shutters. Across the way, Hattie O'Rourke stood in her doorway with her sleeves rolled up, calling out, loud enough for the whole street to hear, "Morning, Mr. Crowe. Your eggs are ready when you want them, and the coffee's hot."
Elias nodded to her and kept walking. He had slept badly, his grazed arm throbbing under the bandage Xiu had tied the night before,
Dr. Bell was waiting for him on the boardwalk outside the surgery, his gray beard catching the light. "You look like a man who didn't sleep," the doctor said.
It counts for nothing, Bell said, kindly. "Dreams don't hold a door. Come inside. I want to look at that arm before the day gets to you."
Inside, the surgery smelled of carbolic and clean linen. Bell unwound the bandage and studied the graze along Elias's forearm. "It will scar," he said. "It will also heal, if you stop tearing it open. Try not to get shot at again today."
Xiu was in the back room, sitting at the small table with a cup of tea gone cold before her. She had been up since before dawn. She looked up when he came in, and her dark eyes searched his face.
Arm? she asked, in her careful English. "It is — worse?"
Better, Elias said. "The doctor says so, and the doctor is a man who does not lie to spare feelings. I have heard him tell a man his leg was broken when the man was still insisting it was only bruised."
She nodded, but her hands stayed clasped around the cup. "Today," she said slowly, "the town — it will choose?"
The town has already chosen, Bell said, from the doorway. "It is only deciding whether to say so out loud."
He was right. By midmorning, Main Street had become a slow, public argument conducted in glances. Sam Whitaker came out of his forge and shook Elias's hand in plain sight. Pastor Marsh walked down from the white church and stopped to speak with Xiu on the boarding-house steps, asking in slow, clear words how her leg was healing, while miners passed and stared.
But for every hand offered, a door closed. The assay office kept its shutters half-drawn. A freighter Elias had known for six years crossed to the other side of the street. At the Gilded Spur, two of Grady's men sat on the porch with their boots up, watching the boarding house the way a man watches a trap he has already set.
And then Sheriff Roy Calloway came down the street with his star pinned crooked on his chest and his big slow walk, and Elias knew before the man opened his mouth that the law was about to be used as a weapon.
Elias Crowe, Calloway said, loud enough for the porch-sitters to hear. "I have a complaint against you. Theft of freight."
Elias went very still. "What freight?"
Four crates of mining timber brackets and two barrels of nails, Calloway said, reading from a paper he held too tightly. "Property of the Red Rock Mining Company, delivered short. Mr. Grady says you shorted the load on your last run and sold the difference."
It was a lie so clean it almost shone. Elias remembered that load perfectly — the brackets, the nails, the case of tinned peaches bound for Pike's store, the forty-pound sack of coffee. He had delivered every piece of it, and Pike's own ledger would prove it. He said so, quietly.
Pike's ledger is not the law, Calloway said, and would not meet his eyes. "The complaint is filed. I have to take you in."
Elias did not steal, Xiu said, stepping forward from the boarding-house door. Her voice was steady, though her hands were shaking. "I was — with the wagon. I saw the crates. All delivered."
Miss, Calloway said, and the word sounded like an apology and a dismissal at once, "you are not a witness the court will take."
Then take me instead, Dr. Bell said, stepping off the boardwalk. "I will stand surety for him. You know this charge is nonsense, Roy. You have known Elias Crowe for ten years."
Calloway's face flushed dark red. "I have a complaint, Josiah. I have to act on it."
Then act on it honestly, Sam Whitaker said, coming up from the forge with a hammer still in his hand. "Hold him an hour. Look at Pike's books. Ask Amos Pike himself. If you lock that man up on Grady's word alone, you will not be enforcing the law. You will be renting it out."
The sheriff looked from face to face — Bell, Sam, Hattie in her doorway, Pastor Marsh on the steps — and Elias saw the fear in him, plain as daylight. Calloway was afraid of Grady. But for the first time, Elias thought he was also afraid of what the town would think if he did Grady's bidding in broad daylight, with witnesses.
Come along, Elias, Calloway said, quieter now. "Just to the jail. We will sort it out."
Elias went. He did not resist, because resisting would have given Grady exactly what he wanted — a reason to call him an outlaw. He walked beside the sheriff down Main Street with his hands empty at his sides, his head up, because Xiu was watching from the boarding-house steps.
The jail was small and hot, a single cell with a barred window onto an alley. Calloway locked the door with a shaking key and stood there, as if he did not know what to do next.