otherwise: Why would a man who filed in April ship a locked trunk to a town he never lived in,
addressed to himself?
30
On the Sunday after the trunk came, Cate did a thing she had been postponing with increasing ingenuity
all week: she rode into Hollow Ford and asked Walter Finch, point blank and in private, whether Henry
Lowry had ever been in the territory before the spring of 1883. Finch went the colour of his own ledger
paper. He said the records were the records. He said a clerk who speculated on the dead lost his
situation. He said, with his eyes on the plat book and his finger moving, for no reason connected with
their conversation, to a page of filings six years old, that the office had been in other hands in seventynine, and that a great many things filed in those years had been filed - he searched for the word with the
desperation of a man searching a pocket for a key he has already lost - informally. Then he closed the
book, too hard, and asked whether she took sugar, though there was no tea. She rode home the six miles
in a silence so complete that the mule turned its ears back at her repeatedly, and that night she wrote in
the book only one line, underlined twice: Finch is not lying to me. Finch is afraid of something that is
not me. It is a distinction she had learned in a schoolroom, and it had never once been useless.
31
The trunk developed, as locked things do, a personality in the household, and Cate, who was not
superstitious, permitted herself to be entirely superstitious about it in private. She used it for a table. She
used it for a seat when she laced her boots. She rested the lamp on it at night and her hand on it,
sometimes, in the middle of a sentence she was writing in the book, the way a speaker rests a hand on a
lectern - for authority, or for company. Ledger the pup slept against it, drawn by whatever pup sense
detects the most important object in any room. She had calculated its weight with the wagon scale at the
mercantile yard in her head a dozen times and argued herself, by turns, into paper and into iron and
once, at three in the morning, into gold, which she dismissed by daylight as a pregnant woman's fantasy
and a schoolteacher's disgrace. What she never did, after that first evening, was reach for the chisel. It
was not principle exactly, and it was not patience exactly. It was the growing conviction, which the
copybook recorded and the rest of her resisted, that the trunk was not hers to open by force because it
was not, in the deepest sense, Henry's to leave - that it belonged to the unfinished year, to McCready, to
whoever had cut letters deep into a stone at the head of her coulee four years before her husband filed on
the land above it. You do not break into another man's sentence. You wait, if you can bear it, to be told.
32
Twice in the week after the trunk arrived, freight wagons coming down from the railhead stopped at the
claim without freight for her, and both times the drivers, in the course of watering their teams at her
spring - a courtesy she granted and charged for in news - asked with an identical, rehearsed casualness
whether the Lowry woman kept anything of her husband's by her, papers and such, that the company or
the county might be wanting for their files. The second driver, finding the question fall flat, improved it
with an offer: the company paid a finder's fee for documents, no questions and no receipts, cash in the
hand. Cate fed both men, watered both teams, answered both with the same flat courtesy - that her
husband's effects were her child's inheritance and not merchandise - and reported both visits in the book
in a hand that got steadier as the sentences got angrier. Then she did three things, in order, with the
clarity of a woman laying a fire. She moved the oilcloth packet of letters into the flour tin. She hung
Henry's watch on a nail inside the chimney breast, where no casual eye would value it. And she sat
down with the trunk between her knees and studied the lock for a full hour, not to open it, but to
memorise it, so that she would know at a glance, forever after, whether anyone else had tried.
33
Chapter Eight - Cheap Money
Silas Crane rode out in person this time, on the Friday, in a buggy with a matched pair that he drove
himself, which in Hollow Ford counted as a declaration of war. He walked around the half-built house
with his hat in his hand and the respectfulness of a man at a graveside, and he admired the south window
opening with the air of a fellow connoisseur, and Cate understood that he had not come to repeat
himself. Men like Crane never repeat themselves. They revise.
"Nineteen hundred," he said. "I have authority now for nineteen hundred dollars, Mrs. Lowry, and a
retained interest for the child - a royalty on the water, if the company develops it, written into the deed
of relinquishment. My principals were impressed, I don't mind telling you, that you got walls up. It
changed their arithmetic." He looked at the roof poles, stacked and waiting. "It will not change the
weather's."
"Why is the spring worth nineteen hundred dollars to a cattle company, Mr. Crane?" Cate asked. "There