the sight of the whole valley. Let the company's lawyer argue with the house. Better men have tried. It
chinks well and it does not move.
88
Chapter Nineteen - The Hearing
The hearing was held on the first Tuesday the roads opened, in the land office at Hollow Ford, which is
to say in a lean-to against the assay building with a stove, eleven chairs, and a crowd in the doorway that
the whole settlement understood to be a jury in everything but law. Cate wore her good dress, unaltered
now, and carried Margaret in the crook of her left arm and the evidence in a satchel in her right hand, the
scarred hand, which did not shake. Gideon sat where witnesses sit, with his field book on his knee and
Ruth's Bible, at Finch's request, under it. Mother Prentice occupied the chair nearest the stove as of
right, and Tomas Reed, sworn retainer, stood guard over the trunk itself - for the trunk had come to town
on Thorne's sled, at Callum's suggestion, because in his experience rooms believed chests - by the door,
with an expression that dared the Continental Land and Grazing Company to make his day complete.
The company's lawyer was young, and expensive, and entirely unprepared for the order in which the
truth had been arranged for him. He opened with the inked plat, fair and false, and the forty rods, and the
defective filing, and he was good: for ten minutes the room listened to a description of Cottonwood
Bench in which a spring changed its allegiance by paperwork and a widow's house stood, by a trick of a
dead man's error, on company grass. Then Finch, clerk of the office, rose at his own table - a thing no
one in Hollow Ford had ever seen a clerk do at a hearing - and filed, in his own name, in full, the
comparison of the two lines from the plat book that had lived under his counter since eighty-one, and sat
down again with his hands flat on the table to keep them from advertising his terror, and the room
understood that the paper had changed sides.
89
Callum's inspection was read into the record in his fence-line hand: corner found as described, line true,
residence continuous, contest not sustained. The affidavit of April the eleventh was produced from the
county's crooked filing and read aloud by the justice, dry as dust and twice as settling. Gideon's
testimony took the longest, because he gave it as he had given the story to Cate in February: bearing by
bearing, with the field book open and his left hand flat on the page, and no ornament anywhere in it
except, at the very end, an answer to the one question the young lawyer - who was not a bad man, only a
hired one, and was learning the difference at speed - put to him on the company's behalf.
"You kept silent, Mr. Thorne, for four years. Through the filing. Through the claimant's - through Mrs.
Lowry's whole autumn, when a word from you would have spared her, by your own account,
considerable distress. Why should this hearing believe a man whose truth arrives so conveniently late?"
90
"Because it doesn't arrive by my convenience," Gideon said. "It arrives by his conditions." He laid his
hand, briefly, on the Bible under the book. "I gave Henry Lowry my word that I would never be the one
to speak of the true line first. That it would be found, in the ground, by somebody with a reason to need
it true, or not at all. His widow found the corner stone in her first week on the claim, with her own
hands, in the rain, before any man told her it existed. Every step since - the books, the affidavit, the
inspection - has followed from her finding, not my telling. I am not the source of any of it, sir. I am the
last of it. The ground spoke first. I'm only the part of the record that can be cross-examined, and I am
obliged to the company for the opportunity, which I have waited four years to be given by somebody
with the standing to give it." He sat down. In the silence that followed, Margaret Lowry, five months
old, made a remark of her own, loud and unsworn, from the crook of her mother's arm, and Mother
Prentice's snort of laughter had to be entered, by the justice's own ruling, as an adjournment of two
minutes for the restoration of order.
It was Crane who ended it. Crane, who had sat beside his company's lawyer all morning in his good
coat, with his soft hands folded, listening to a case come apart in the order Cate had arranged for it -
ground, books, record, living - rose, uninvited, in the restored order, and asked the hearing's leave to
speak to his principals' position. The young lawyer, to his credit, sat down and let him.
91
"I knew Henry Lowry for two days," Crane said, "in April of last year, in this town. He lodged his
affidavit on one of them. He showed me - " he stopped, and looked for the first time directly at Cate, and
she saw the tired, ageing sharper of the October buggy, the man who respected the opposition - "he
showed me nothing at all, Mrs. Lowry. That was the showing. A man with a false line to sell shows a
buyer everything, twice. Your husband showed me a receipt for a filing fee and asked me the price of
nails in Hollow Ford, and I have done this work for twenty years, and I wrote to my principals that night