He rode down to the claim on the third morning, while Cate was still learning how the broadaxe wanted
to bite, and he sat his horse at the edge of the cleared square and watched her work for a full minute
before he spoke, which she understood was his version of a knock at the door.
"You're splitting shakes with a broadaxe," he said. "It'll do it, but it'll take the arms off you by
Thursday."
"I am open to instruction," Cate said, "from a man who introduces himself."
"Thorne. Gideon Thorne. My fence is the north line." He was forty-four, tall in the saddle, grey coming
into a dark beard, and he had the stillness of a man who has arranged his life so that very little can be
taken from it. "I'll say my piece once. This bench winters hard. The wind comes off the high country and
there's nothing between it and your door but six miles of grass. The creek trail washes out in the first
freeze-up and some years it stays out till March. A woman alone - " he looked, briefly and without
apology, at the shape of her under her coat - "in your fix, alone, in a tent, in October - ma'am, the kindest
thing this country does to people who won't listen is bury them shallow in the spring. Sell to Crane. Take
his train."
"I have taken one train on another person's advice this year," Cate said. "I was burying my husband at
the end of it. I'll make my own arrangements now."
Something crossed his face then, not anger - recognition, unwanted, like a man hearing his own name in
a stranger's mouth. He gathered his reins.
10
"Suit yourself," he said. "Don't come to my door when the snow does. I've buried enough neighbours."
And he rode north through the cottonwoods without looking back, and Cate stood with the broadaxe in
her hands and watched him until he was a small dark shape against the pale grass, and she thought: there
goes a man who has practised that speech. She wondered how many years he had been practising it, and
at whom, before there was anyone on the bench to say it to.
She worked until dark. She learned the broadaxe a little. She learned more about her own back, and
about the particular loneliness of a place where the only other human soul for six miles had just formally
declined to be one.
That night, and for many nights after, Cate rehearsed the conversation with Gideon Thorne the way
generals refight lost battles, finding the better sentence always one hour too late. She might have said
that she had buried exactly as many neighbours as he had, if you counted a husband as a neighbour,
which marriage surely did. She might have said that a man warning a woman off land six miles from his
door was not protecting her but protecting the view from his own window, which had contained no other
human being for five years and had grown comfortable in the arrangement. She said none of it, aloud, to
the tent walls, more than once, with the broadaxe leaning in the corner like a second, ruder guest. But
underneath the rehearsing she was honest enough, in the dark, to admit the thing she would not have
admitted at noon: that some splinter of his warning was in her, working. That she was afraid - not of
work, not of weather, not even, strangely, of the birth, which her body seemed to regard as its own
business competently arranged - but of the arithmetic Crane had named. One woman. One winter. One
hundred and sixty acres of indifference. She held the fear up, looked at it the way she had taught
children to look at a sum that frightened them, and divided it into its days. A day she could do. She had
done this one.
11
For his part, Gideon Thorne spent the evening of his first visit home in a state he would have died rather
than name. He mended harness that did not need mending. He walked his north fence in the dark, which
no sane man does for pleasure, and stood at the corner where his land met hers and looked south at a tent
lantern burning on ground that had been empty, in every sense that mattered, for five years. It was not
the woman he objected to, he told the fence post, with the honesty darkness permits. It was the
arithmetic of her. A widow with child, a tent, and a deadline, planted squarely in the one direction he had
arranged never to look. He had built his peace the way he built his woodpile, log by log, each grief laid
square and tight so no weather could get between them, and she had arrived with a broadaxe and begun,
without knowing it, to take the pile apart from the far side. He finished the fence walk at midnight no
wiser than he had started, except for one entry in the ledger he kept of himself, which he would have
burned if it had been written down: he had noticed the square of cleared ground was exactly where he
would have put a house himself, and he had respected the dead man for it, and respect, in Gideon
Thorne's economy, was the first coin of a currency he had sworn never to spend again.
12
The church elder's visit, which Cate had braced for as a siege, turned out to be an inspection of another
kind. Elder Pomeroy walked the claim boundary where she showed it to him, examined the corner stone