inches to food. He said it at her table, to the fire, as a report on stock, nothing more; and Cate
understood that she was hearing, in the grammar he could afford, about every other silence he had ever
dug down to. She did not console him. Consolation, between them, had always been work or nothing.
Instead she set him, the next thaw, to the repair of the winter's harness with Margaret asleep in the
basket at his feet, and by spring the calf in the lean-to had a name in the book, the hives' tally had a plan
beside it, and the house had acquired, without any entry at all, a second keeper of its accounts. Some
things, she wrote, are proved up only by being wintered. She meant the claim. She allowed the margin to
mean the rest.
66
Chapter Fifteen - Paper Weather
The paper came on the ninth of February, as predicted, travelling light: a single rider, a leather wallet, a
county process server with frostbite in one ear and the manner of a man delivering weather. Cate read it
standing in her doorway with Margaret against her shoulder and the wind reading over the other.
It was, in form, a notice of contest. The Continental Land and Grazing Company, by its agent Silas
Crane, contested the homestead filing of Henry Lowry, deceased, now claimed by his widow Catherine
Lowry, Claim No. 1147, Cottonwood Bench - on two grounds, set out in a hand as clean as a bank
statement. First, that the original filing was defective, the description of the parcel resting upon a survey
line run in 1879 and never lawfully returned, whereby the parcel as filed overlapped a prior selection
and was void from its beginning. Second, that the claimant had not resided continuously upon the claim,
having been absent from the dwelling during the month of November, at the house of another.
"November," Cate said aloud, to the server, to the wind, to the child. "The month of the blizzard. The
month of the birth."
"Aye, ma'am," the server said, miserable, tugging his collar up. "I only carry it. The hearing's set for the
first Tuesday the roads open, at the land office, and testimony's to be filed ahead, on account of the - "
he searched for the official word and surrendered to the human one - "on account of everybody being
tired of it by spring. Mr. Crane says - I was to say - Mr. Crane says his principals would still settle,
ma'am. Generous, was the word he supplied. If the widow would relinquish before the hearing, there's
no - exposure - was the other word he supplied."
67
"Exposure," Cate repeated. She felt Margaret's small heat against her, and the house warm at her back,
and the spring running black and unfrozen in its basin below, for cattle and deer and neighbours and one
land company that proposed, on paper, to fence it with a defective filing. Behind the clean handwriting
the whole autumn rearranged itself at last into the shape she had been copying, all winter, in the margins
of her book. Crane's arithmetic did have a date on it. The date was a hearing. The house had to stand,
and she had to reside, and Henry's filing had to be honest - and it was the third of those, the dead man's
honesty, that the paper now proposed to put on trial, in a room, before clerks, on the evidence of a line
run four years before his widow ever heard the name of the valley.
She signed the receipt with a hand that did not shake - the copybook had trained it - and she took the
notice inside, and laid it on the crate table under the south window, in Henry's light, and weighted it with
his watch, and she wrote beneath it in the book, in the plain column, in full, with no small hand and no
margin: Feb 9. The contest is Henry's year, come at last with a date on it. Good. A thing with a date can
be met. What is needed: the line, the stone, the name, the trunk, and the man who ran the chain. All five
exist. Four are in this room's keeping. The fifth rides in for supper on Thursdays. - She closed the book,
and put the water on, and began, methodically, to plan a defence the way she had once planned a school
term: first principles first, and nothing, nothing at all, left to be found out in the wrong order ever again.
68
Finch came out himself, three days later, on a borrowed horse, in a state of nerves that he attempted to
disguise as an official visit and surrendered, by the fire, within the half hour. The contest had been built,
he told her - off the record, a phrase he used eleven times as a drowning man uses a plank - out of
records that had passed through his own office, and one that had not: a plat, produced by the company
from its own files, showing Cottonwood Bench sectioned on a line a full forty rods west of the line
Henry filed on. Forty rods put the spring, the house ground, and the big corner stone itself on the
company's side of the description. Forty rods was the whole case. "In seventy-nine," Finch whispered,
with his eyes on the trunk, "this office was kept by a man named Odell, who filed what he was handed
and asked what he was told to ask, which was nothing. The survey that year was a government contract.
Party chief was a man - " He stopped, and looked at her, and the fear she had filed in October under