with a survey chain in three counties, before the diphtheria winter; that he had run lines for half the
ranches on the north fork, and for the government besides; and that he had not touched a transit or a
chain since seventy-nine, not for money, not for friendship, not for the county itself when the boundary
dispute of eighty-one had needed exactly his gift and gone begging without it. "Gave it up whole,"
Sykes said, "like a man giving up drink. Whatever he saw through that little telescope in seventy-nine,
ma'am, he didn't care to see it twice." He said it without malice and without emphasis, and spat, and
went back to his horses, and left the year standing in the air between Cate and her copybook like smoke
that would not clear. That night the entry practically wrote itself: 1879 again. G.T. a surveyor, 1879, and
will not say. Henry a surveyor, in a place he never named, 1879 unaccounted. I am building a house, she
wrote, on top of the one year of my husband's life I was never given. She underlined nothing. She was
learning that some facts are too heavy for emphasis, and simply have to be carried level.
27
The quilt arrived in the same week as a change in Gideon that Tomas Reed, who missed nothing that
happened within earshot of a horse, reported to the mercantile at length: Thorne had been seen buying
lamp oil at Sill's. Lamp oil, in quantities. Thorne, whose house had shown no light after dark in five
years, whose whole arrangement with the world was conducted, as the saying went, by daylight or not at
all. The mercantile held several theories - company for the winter, a lamp for the bee cellar, a courtship
so improbable that merely naming it cost the theorist a round of coffee - and arrived, by consensus, at
none. Cate, hearing it third-hand while buying salt, said nothing at all, but she entered it in the book that
night in the plain column, between the weather and the work done, where it belonged and did not
belong: Oct 24. G.T. observed purchasing lamp oil in quantity. No conclusion drawn. She sat looking at
the entry for a while, in her tent, by the light of her own lamp, six miles from his. Then she added, in the
small hand, in the margin, where all the true entries lived: Two lights on the bench this winter, perhaps.
It is amazing what the dark has to say about that.
28
Chapter Seven - The Trunk
The trunk arrived on a Tuesday, in the freight wagon from the railhead, and it arrived the way trouble
usually does in a small place: as news first and as an object second. Tomas Reed, the depot boy, rode out
ahead of the wagon at what his mule considered a gallop, with his penny earned and his story already
improving in the telling.
"There's a box come for your husband, ma'am," he said. "Been setting in the freight shed at the railhead
since - " he considered the weight of accuracy and put it down gently - "a good while. The agent there is
new and he cleaned the shed, is why. It's addressed H. LOWRY, HOLLOW FORD, in paint, and the
freight's owing on it, but Mr. Sill - I mean the depot master - he says to bring it out and settle after,
seeing as - " Tomas stopped, stricken by the end of his own sentence.
"Seeing as my husband is dead," Cate said. "It's all right, Tomas. It's a fact, not a splinter. It doesn't hurt
worse for being touched."
The trunk was oak, iron-bound, with brass corners green at the seams, and it was heavy the way things
are heavy when they are full of paper or full of iron - she could not tell which, and she turned that
uncertainty over all afternoon like a stone in a shoe. It had a hasp and a lock the size of a man's fist, and
no key. The key would have been on Henry's ring. Henry's ring - the plain band, the keys, the little
folding knife - had come back to her from Helena in a paper envelope through the post, along with his
watch, stopped, and she had inventoried it a hundred times in the night watches: band, watch, knife, two
keys, both small, both accounted for. A shed key. A desk key. No trunk key, large or otherwise.
29
She set the trunk in the tent, out of the rain that threatened, and sat looking at it while the light went. She
thought about prising it. She had a pry bar, a cold chisel, and a justification that any court in
Christendom would accept: she was his widow, his heir, his executor, the mother of his child, and winter
was coming. She thought about it the way she had thought, at fourteen, about reading her sister's diary -
completely, and with full knowledge of exactly what she was doing - and she set the chisel down unused, because a locked thing left by a man who locked nothing else in his life felt less like property than
like a sentence he had not finished, and she found she wanted to hear him finish it, somehow, in his own
way and time.
"Not yet," she said to the trunk. "We have a roof to raise. You wait."
But she copied into the household book, under the entry for the small stone: Trunk, oak, brass corners,
lock large, no key. Freight owing, $1.40. Arrived Oct 16, five months after it should have. And
underneath, because the book was becoming something more than accounts and she no longer pretended