This is the best-watered bench between here and the Musselshell, and the wind misses the worst of it by
fifty feet. There's men would kill for this spring in a dry year." He stood and put his hat on. "Sills are
down. The rest is only work."
He was gone before she could say anything that would have embarrassed them both, but at the edge of
the cleared square his horse stopped, or he stopped it.
"Wall logs Thursday," he said, to the cottonwoods generally. "If the weather holds. I've a team that isn't
consulted about its opinions." And then he rode on, and Cate looked at the two great sills lying square
and true on their stones, the first fact of the house, and put her hand flat on the nearest one as she had on
the corner stone, feeling the green wood cold under her palm.
20
What neither of them said, all that first working day, was the word help, and Cate came to understand
that the whole arrangement depended on the word never being spoken. Gideon Thorne could move her
sills because a mule was down, because a story might get told in town, because a Christian reputation
was a kind of fence he maintained along with the wire ones. He could not move them because a widow
needed him to. Need, between two proud people, is a currency neither can afford to mint, so they traded
instead in fictions as carefully kept as accounts: he was buying quiet; she was accepting instruction; the
sills were a problem in physics that happened to be located on her land. She recognised the arrangement
because she used its mirror image herself every day of her widowhood. She was not surviving, which
would invite pity. She was proving up a claim, which invited only respect, or opposition, both of which
were easier to eat with. That evening she entered the day in the book without any of this philosophy, in
the plain style the copybook demanded: Oct 9. Sills set, both, true and level. G.T. present, unpaid,
unthanked at his own insistence. Mule June recovered by rest and oats. Then, in the margin, in smaller
writing: He sights a log the way Henry read a map. I must stop noticing men's hands. It is grief, not
character.
21
There is a stage in any great labour when the work stops being a list and becomes a place the worker
lives inside, and Cate reached it somewhere in the second week, when her hands began to know the
tools before her mind consulted them and the broadaxe, the saw, and the froe stopped being borrowed
skills and became a vocabulary. She was proud of her hands that autumn in a way she had never been
permitted to be proud of her mind: blistered, then calloused, then competent, they were the visible
record of the whole enterprise, and she caught herself holding them up to the lantern some nights the
way another woman might study a letter. On the bad days - and there were bad days, when the wind
found the tent and the child sat hard on some nerve and Henry's absence arrived fresh, like news - she
worked slower and did not stop, because she had formulated, out of her years of schoolrooms, the only
rule she trusted: the day you cannot do the hard thing, do the next thing, and let the list carry you until
your heart comes back to work, as it always does, like a dog, at supper time.
22
The letters in the oilcloth packet had an order, and the order was a biography Cate could recite in her
sleep: Galena, the schoolhouse, a dance where a surveyor home between seasons had asked the teacher
to hold his hat while he fixed a lady's wagon wheel, and had somehow never given the hat back, having
contrived to return it in person eleven times. She read them that October in rotation, one a night, no
more, rationing a dead man's company the way she rationed coffee, and what she was listening for - she
admitted it to the book, in the small hand, on the ninth - was not affection. The affection was
documented beyond doubt. She was listening for the seam. Every life told in letters has one: the place
where the story, however honest, has been tailored. Henry's letters ran smooth as a plumb line from
boyhood to the schoolhouse door and then jumped, in a single spring, to Virginia City and the survey
camps - and somewhere inside that jump, inside the lost season no letter described, a man's whole
character had apparently been re-cut. Men in Hollow Ford liked him and would not say why. Men in
Hollow Ford crossed the street from his name and would not say why either. She folded the last letter
back into the packet no wiser and considerably less willing to be comforted, and she wrote: I married the
tailor as well as the cloth. It remains to be seen what I am wearing.
23
Chapter Six - Hauling Logs
Thursday the weather held, and Thursday became the pattern of the autumn: Gideon Thorne arrived in
the blue hour before full light with his team and his tools and a face that announced he was doing none
of it, and the walls of Henry Lowry's house rose a course at a time out of the bench grass.
Cottonwood is poor timber and both of them knew it - it warps, it checks, it rots where it touches earth -
but it was what the coulee grew and what Henry had cut, and there is a loyalty in using a dead man's