said finally. "And it seemed - unneighbourly - to let you do it not knowing why I might be - short - at
certain moments."
"Mr. Thorne," Cate said, when she could trust her voice, "there has not been one moment."
41
"There will be," he said, "when the crying starts. That's why I'm telling you now, in daylight, with the
wall between us." He drove the last handful of clay home and smoothed it with his palm, gentle as a
man stroking a horse. "I'll do my work. Whatever it costs me, I'll do it. But I wanted it said by me, first,
instead of found out. That's a thing your husband understood, I think." He glanced at her then, quick and
almost alarmed at his own words. "From his letters. From the way he laid out this ground. A man who
does the hard part first. That's all I meant."
Outside, the needling had thickened, and the temperature was falling through the floor of the day, and
the first snow of the year began to come down on Cottonwood Bench in earnest - small, hard, driven
grains at first, then slower, then in great soft flakes out of a suddenly quiet sky, settling on the new roof,
on the corner stone, on the carved H.L. and on the older marks beneath, covering all the writing in the
world with a clean page.
"Till first snow," Cate said, half to herself, remembering Crane.
"Then it's first snow," said Gideon, "and he's too late, and so are we, for anything but finishing." And he
picked up his bucket and went on chinking as the snow came down around them both, because there was
nothing else in either of their lives, by then, that they knew how to do about anything.
42
There was a supper, the night the chinking finished, that Cate would remember on the far side of
everything that winter still intended for her: beans and bacon and the last of the dried-apple pies, eaten
in the unfinished house with the fire lit in a fireplace still open to the sky at the top of the chimney
breast, Mother Prentice presiding from the crate, Tomas asleep against the trunk with his mouth open,
and Gideon Thorne - who had declined, on his arrival, to stay to any supper - seated on a wall log with a
plate he had accepted as if it had been served on him by process of law. The old midwife told stories
against the medical profession, living and dead. Gideon, at some point in his second cup of coffee and to
his own visible astonishment, laughed - a short, rusty, unpractised sound, like a gate opening that had
been wired shut for years - and then looked at the fire as if the fire had done it without his permission.
Cate said nothing. Some things you chink around as carefully as any crack in a wall, because the
weather you are keeping out is real and the warmth you are keeping in is new and does not yet know its
own strength. When they had gone, she stood a long time in her doorway watching two lanterns cross
the bench in different directions, north and south, hers the only light that stayed.
43
On the last Sunday of October, Cate rode to church in Hollow Ford in her good dress, altered with a
panel she had sewn herself and wore without shame, and took the sacrament, and afterwards stood in the
churchyard in the thin sun while the settlement performed the slow, serious business of deciding, in her
hearing and out of it, what she now was. She heard the verdicts forming as clearly as if they had been
put to a vote. She was no longer the widow who had arrived in September, an object of wagers. She was
the woman whose roof had gone on before Elder Pomeroy's barn repairs, whose chinking was the
straightest on the north fork, who had refused nineteen hundred dollars in a voice the hotel keeper had
imitated twice at supper. A delegation of two wives, appointed by no one and understood by everyone,
presented her with a quilt - top pieced from flour sacks and one square of unmistakable wedding-dress
silk - with the explanation that it was not charity but ballast, a house not being a house, in the opinion of
the north fork, until it contained something made by other women's hands for no reason of business.
Cate accepted it with both hands and dry eyes and cried about it for an hour in the wagon going home,
where only June the mule could testify. She spread it on the bed in the new house that night, the first
finished thing in the first finished room, and the house, which had been an argument, became for the
first time a place where a child might reasonably be expected to live.
44
The diary of the claim, if anyone but its author had read it that autumn, would have looked like the driest
document in the territory: columns of figures, weather reduced to single words - fair, blow, first ice - and
yet Cate guarded it with her life, because she knew what it actually was. It was the record of a woman
becoming equal to a place, set down nightly in a hand that never once shook, though the woman
sometimes did. She wrote it for the child. She wrote it for the land office, which might someday demand
proof not merely of residence but of intent. She wrote it, on the nights when the wind worried the tent
like a dog at a door, for the other reader she would never name even in the margin: herself, at seventy, in