Owen had never been asked a question about five years. In his ward he usually thought of tomorrow's deliveries and next month's rent demands. Nessa had ruled through urgent decisions partly because urgency made the future appear as an insult to the present. He returned to the council building with a list of things he could no longer decide by intuition. Iris made copies of the road survey and sent them to all four captains. He asked her to put the contractor's alternatives on the agenda, and she reminded him that the next meeting had already been allocated to the boundary appeals. 'Then the captains have to choose what they defer,' he said. She gave him a look that suggested he had at last discovered an ordinary truth about a governing body. There were never enough afternoons to settle everything, and no procedure could create more hours. It could only make the sacrifice visible.
At the meeting, the southern captain, Henry Lyle, argued that the transport cooperative had accepted the risks of the route when it paid the deposit. Leona disagreed. The cooperative had paid for an agreement, not a map. Catrin asked whether the council could negotiate shared use of a private loading lane behind the market. Evelyn said the lane's owner had already demanded a sum that would bankrupt the cooperative within two seasons. Iris entered the figures in a column. Owen suggested splitting the engineering work into stages, but Martin said the machinery would cost more if brought back twice. It was a decision with no painless version, and the captains spent two hours trying to find one. Eventually they voted to repair the road fully, financed partly through a temporary contribution from the wards whose trade would benefit most directly. They required a published schedule of costs and a date for renewed access. Henry voted against it and said so in the record. Nobody expelled him from the room.
The decision produced the first public anger Owen had faced as boss. A market association accused him of imposing a tax by another name. Two drivers said they would rather keep using the detour than pay for a repair that ought to have been funded years earlier. A merchant who had benefited from Nessa's intervention during the previous winter announced that the council had become weak. Iris brought Owen copies of the complaints and asked which he intended to answer. 'All of them,' he said before thinking. 'You can answer the substance of all of them,' she replied. 'You cannot write every unhappy person a different future.' They drafted a single explanation with the cost, the rejected options, and the names of the captains who had voted. Owen insisted that it include Henry's dissent, even though Henry had made no effort to soften his criticism. 'It is his ward,' Owen said. 'They should know he spoke for them.'
Three days later Evelyn called to report that the cooperative had approved the interim arrangement. She sounded no more affectionate than when she had first arrived. She wanted a copy of the engineering schedule and would send another letter if the dates slipped. Owen promised the schedule, not his personal protection. As he ended the call, he noticed that he was not disappointed. Respect did not need to sound like gratitude. He went down to the lower room to help Iris move the filing cabinets away from the damp wall. The room was not large enough for all four wards' old records, and the ceiling near the stairs had begun to stain. When he mentioned the stain Iris said the repair had been requested twice during Nessa's tenure and once before. He asked why it had not been done. She handed him the estimates. The council had chosen to spend the money on a heating failure that threatened the upstairs apartment. He could see the logic. He could also see the wet plaster. The new order of business, he realised, would consist partly of ordinary things that no one could narrate as a victory.
Leona's first months in the fourth chair were made difficult not by the captains who opposed her but by the people who had sent her. The founding ward had survived its exclusion by developing a habit of consulting itself. Residents met in a back room above a bakery, and decisions that required a council response were discussed until the people present could agree on at least a question. Once the seat was restored, however, the meetings began to resemble a parliament of grievances. Every older shopkeeper remembered a service that had been taken away. Every younger trader had a plan for reclaiming its costs. Leona arrived at the council with pages of demands and went home to discover that bringing a question upstairs was not the same as bringing back an answer. Owen learned this when she asked whether she could use the empty room next to the records office for a standing weekly meeting with her constituents. Iris said the room contained files that had not yet been catalogued. Owen suggested that the files could be moved. Catrin asked whether the other wards would receive equal access. Henry asked who would pay for the clerk who would have to supervise the room. A simple request opened into three questions about rights and resources.