Two months later the tram construction began, and the shared service desk received its first test. A drainage problem closed the western vehicle entrance unexpectedly. The desk arranged a temporary route and notified the affected businesses before the morning shift. The packaging company still lost an hour of work. The forklift driver reported that the temporary crossing lacked a clear warning sign. The sign was installed that afternoon. None of the problems justified declaring the arrangement successful or a failure in full. They were evidence that the arrangement needed adjustment, and the adjustments could be traced to a person authorized to make them. Owen read the reports in the lower room while the afternoon light moved across the table. He had once expected the head of the council to decide which ward owned each inch of the map. He now saw that a line could be useful without becoming a verdict on everyone who lived and worked around it.
At the review hearing the tenants asked to keep the shared service desk even after the tram opened. Henry said a temporary fix could not automatically become a permanent structure. Catrin said the fact that it had worked deserved consideration. Leona proposed a one-year trial with transparent costs and a right to appeal specific service failures. Iris calculated that the arrangement could be funded by reallocating money previously spent on duplicative administration. The measure passed unanimously. Owen was almost disappointed by the absence of drama. He had become used to hearing progress announced through confrontation, with one person accused and another vindicated. Here the best result was that several people had found a practical answer and nobody needed to claim the chair at the head of the table as a prize.
The council's first annual review under Owen was held on a day of thin sunlight. Iris had arranged the papers in four sets, one for each ward, and a fifth for the public archive. She opened with the record of decisions rather than a speech about leadership. Some promises had been fulfilled. The founding ward had its elected representative and an established right to bring disputes. Several financial records were clearer, the river road was open again, and the reporting procedures had been tested in ordinary cases. Other commitments remained unfinished. The new lift was not yet installed. The medical transport review had identified journeys the budget could not fund. The riverfront workshops were still negotiating the practical details of relocation. Owen listened as each captain reported a difficulty that the council had not solved and resisted the urge to defend every delay personally.
Henry spoke first about the southern contributions. His ward had paid more than it expected and believed several services could be provided at lower cost. He presented alternative figures and asked the finance office to examine them before the next budget. Catrin thanked him for the work and cautioned that a lower contract price might conceal reduced staffing. Leona asked whether the affected workers would be consulted. Henry said he had not invited them to the initial calculation because he wanted to establish what the business could afford. Lydia Crow, attending from the public seating area, asked whether he considered workers an expense to be adjusted after the important decisions were made. He said he considered them people who depended on a viable service. Iris recorded both views. Owen proposed a joint review of the contracts with the workers' representatives included from the beginning. Henry accepted, though reluctantly.
Leona presented a list of appeals from the founding ward. Several had been resolved through direct records checks; others remained contested because evidence had been lost years ago. She refused to announce a total sum recovered or a number of people satisfied. Instead she described what the office could prove, what it could not, and where a fair procedure had prevented confident but unsupported claims. Some residents had wanted more decisive results. Leona said the council should not buy the appearance of effectiveness by inventing certainty. Owen remembered Brigid's letters and the months in which nobody had answered them directly. He thanked Leona for making the unanswered questions visible and did not ask her to shorten the report for the sake of a pleasing summary.
Catrin's report concerned the west. She described the ward election, the access rules, the workshop negotiations, and the new notification system for changes affecting workers' shifts. Tomas Greeve attended and challenged a cost figure in the river road account. The finance clerk produced the corrected summary and the corresponding invoices. Tomas accepted the arithmetic but disputed the judgment that the expenditure had been necessary. Catrin said that disagreement could be recorded without reopening a completed contract on the basis of arithmetic that both sides now accepted. Owen watched the exchange with a mixture of admiration and relief. Catrin had been his colleague and friend before he became boss. She was now a captain capable of disagreeing with him, and her authority did not require his protection.
Iris closed the review by presenting the office's own errors. A return had been filed in the wrong folder. Two public notices had used outdated wording. A maintenance schedule was published late. Each had been corrected and accompanied by a change intended to reduce the chance of repetition. The list was not flattering. It also demonstrated that the office had begun treating a mistake as something to document and repair rather than something to conceal until it became an accusation. Owen asked the captains whether they wished to amend the review. Henry added a dissent about costs. Leona requested clearer information about access for people unable to attend evening meetings. Catrin asked for a date by which the remaining transport questions would receive an answer. The amendments were accepted, and the record was signed.