The acting boss kept her sister’s ward out of the council. Then her son pushed her ballot aside and asked the captains to choose who would give the orders.

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Henry argued that extending the policy would make the council unable to appoint anyone. In a city where people had worked together for decades, everybody knew somebody who needed a permit, a grant, or access to a loading bay. Catrin said disclosure was not the same as disqualification. Leona suggested a register of interests open to the captains and available in redacted form to the wards. Iris wanted clear guidance about what counted as a relevant relationship, because an obligation no one could define would become a tool for accusing inconvenient people. Owen proposed a two-part rule: disclose relationships that could reasonably be seen as influencing the decision, and withdraw from a vote when there was a direct personal or financial interest. Henry said he would support the first part and objected to the second if the remaining votes could deadlock. The meeting produced no agreement. For once Owen was relieved that the argument continued. A policy introduced purely to rebut a leaflet would deserve the suspicion it was intended to answer.

Two days later he received an invitation to meet Tomas Greeve, who was now publicly campaigning against the road contribution. Tomas suggested a private conversation at a café near the warehouses and said he would bring documents proving the council had misrepresented its accounts. Iris advised Owen not to meet alone and not to promise anything before seeing the papers. Owen invited Catrin to attend. Tomas arrived with an accountant named Adrian Shaw and several printouts of council figures. Adrian had identified a discrepancy between the published road budget and a later maintenance estimate. The amount was real. Owen took the pages, asked where the newer estimate had come from, and discovered that Iris had attached it to a supplementary report issued after the first publication. The council had not updated the summary table. The fuller report contained the correct figure, but a reader comparing two documents would reasonably assume the office had changed its account without explanation.

Tomas looked delighted when Owen agreed that the public summary was misleading. 'Then you'll cancel the contribution,' he said. Owen told him a correction to the public document did not by itself invalidate the vote. Adrian said the discrepancy could affect whether residents considered the cost justified. That was fair. They agreed to issue a clear amendment and to invite written questions before the next payment became due. Tomas called this an admission of wrongdoing. Owen said it was an admission of a reporting mistake. Tomas laughed. 'You think words will save you.' Catrin closed her notebook and told him that words were what the council had used to charge the wards, and if the words were wrong the people paying had a right to see them corrected. Adrian looked at her with new interest. Tomas seemed irritated to have lost the monopoly on righteous objection.

The corrected summary was posted in all four offices. Owen signed it with Iris and included the original figures so that readers could see what had changed. In the western ward, some people remained convinced the council had hidden money. Others were impressed that a mistake had been acknowledged without anyone being removed from office. Most were concerned chiefly with whether their next payment would be higher. Owen learned not to treat the absence of applause as failure. The corrected document was more useful than a speech about transparency would have been. Iris noticed that he had written a sentence explaining the source of the error rather than assigning blame to the clerk who prepared the first table. She said that was sensible, provided he did not begin protecting clerks from responsibility simply because they had less power than he did. He asked whether she ever allowed anyone to enjoy a compliment. She answered that compliments were best used after the work was checked.

At the next meeting, the conflict-of-interest policy passed in a revised form. Captains would declare close personal and business ties related to a matter under consideration. Where a direct benefit was possible, the council would decide whether the captain should withdraw, with reasons recorded. Owen disclosed his relationship with Catrin in the discussion of her acting appointment, even though the arrangement had been known to everybody. Henry disclosed his brother's ownership of a warehouse affected by the road repairs. Leona disclosed that a cousin operated one of the transport firms represented by Evelyn's cooperative. The list made the council appear more entangled than before. Owen understood why previous administrations had preferred to avoid it. The ties had not been created by writing them down. Now the people affected could consider them alongside the decisions. In the western office the anonymous leaflets stopped appearing after a fortnight. No one claimed to know who had distributed them. The policy remained in force, long after the controversy that prompted it had become old news.

News in the same category

The acting boss kept her sister’s ward out of the council. Then her son pushed her ballot aside and asked the captains to choose who would give the orders.

45 Part