Questions Ethan Should Not Ask
Ethan Parker woke the next morning with the camera still sitting on the kitchen table, and he did not touch it for a long time. He made coffee in the small pot he kept beside the sink, and he stood at the window and watched the fog lift slowly from the gardens of Maplewood. The house was quiet, and the tools were quiet, and the only sound was the slow drip of the tap he had promised to fix. He thought about Emily Carter, and about the way her voice had shaken when she begged him not to watch the camera. He thought about the girl on the screen, and about the lake, and about the man whose face he had not quite seen. He wanted to ask questions, but he did not know which questions were safe, and he did not know who would answer them honestly.
He drove into town after breakfast, and he stopped at the hardware shop for nails and a new hinge. Tom Bennett was behind the counter, and he looked up and smiled when he saw Ethan. Tom had known Ethan for years, and he knew the look on his face when something was wrong. He asked if the old house was giving him trouble, and Ethan said that the house was fine, but that the people connected to it were not. Tom put down the box of nails and leaned on the counter, and he waited, because he knew that Ethan would talk when he was ready. Ethan told him about the camera, and about Emily, and about the girl at the lake. He did not tell him everything, because he did not know everything himself, and he did not want to spread a story that might hurt an innocent person.
Tom listened without interrupting, and when Ethan finished, he shook his head slowly. He said that the Carter house had always carried a sad story, and that everyone in Maplewood knew a little of it and pretended to know nothing at all. He said that Anna Carter had run away ten years ago, or so people said, and that her family had never really recovered. He said that Emily had been the strong one, the one who stayed and looked after the house, and that she had never spoken about her sister to anyone in town. Tom warned Ethan to be careful, because old secrets in a small town could be dangerous, and because powerful men did not like to be reminded of the past. Ethan thanked him, and he paid for the nails, and he left the shop with more questions than he had brought in.
When he returned to the house, Emily was waiting on the porch, and she looked as if she had not slept. She asked him if he had watched more of the tape, and he told her that he had not, because he had promised her that he would not. She thanked him, but her eyes were full of fear, and Ethan could see that she did not quite believe him. He asked her why she was so afraid of the camera, and she said that some things were better left alone, and that the past could not be changed. He asked her about Anna, and she turned away, and she said that her sister had made her own choices, and that it was not his place to ask. Ethan wanted to press her, but he saw the pain in her face, and he stopped.
That evening, Ethan sat alone in the kitchen, and he wrote down every question he could think of. Who was the man at the lake? Why had Anna filmed him? Why had Emily begged him not to watch? Why had the police closed the case so quickly? Who had hidden the camera in the attic? He knew that each question could lead to trouble, and he knew that Emily had asked him to stop, but he also knew that he could not forget the girl on the screen. He put the notebook away, and he looked at the camera, and he told himself that he would wait, and that he would give Emily time to trust him. But in his heart, he knew that the questions would not wait for long. Sooner or later, someone would have to ask them aloud, and Ethan feared that the someone would be him, in a house full of secrets.