The Old Policeman Remembers
The next morning Detective Sarah Lawson pulled the grey box with Anna Carter's name on it from the basement of the Maplewood police station, and she carried it up the stairs to her office. Inside she found the old case file, a thin folder with only a few pages, a map of the woods behind the Carter house, and a list of the people who had been questioned. She read the file twice, slowly. The search had been called off after only three days, and the report said that Anna had run away, but there was no note to explain how the police had reached that conclusion. There was no record of a fight, no record of a boyfriend, and no record of money taken from the house. A girl who runs away takes something with her, and Anna had taken nothing at all.
Detective Lawson drove out to the edge of town that afternoon to see Frank Doyle, the policeman who had been in charge of the search ten years ago. Frank was seventy now, retired, and he lived in a small house with a garden full of roses. He opened the door with a smile, and he invited her in for tea. When she told him why she had come, his smile faded, and he sat down heavily in his chair. He said that he had thought about Anna Carter many times over the years, and that he had never been easy in his mind about the case. He had wanted to keep searching, but he had been told to stop.
Frank told her that on the night Anna had vanished, he had been the first officer to reach the Carter house. Emily had been crying in the kitchen, and her father had been ill in bed, and the house had been strangely quiet in a way that frightened him. He had found the back door open, and there had been mud, and the garden gate had been standing open. He had wanted to search the garden properly, but the senior officer on duty had told him that the girl had run away, and that there was no need to make a fuss. Frank said that he had argued, but that he had been young, and that he had done what he was told.
Then Frank told her something that was not in the file. He said that late that night, after the search had been called off, he had seen a dark car parked near the Carter house, and that a tall man had been standing beside it, talking on a telephone. Frank had not thought much of it at the time, but now, ten years later, he remembered the man's voice, and the way he had looked up at the house. Frank said that the man had been Richard Hale, the town councilman, and that Hale had seen him and had waved, as if there was nothing wrong at all. Frank had gone home and had tried to forget it, but he never had.
Detective Lawson asked Frank why he had never written any of this down, and Frank looked down at his hands. He said that the day after Anna had vanished, Hale had come to the station, and that he had spoken to the chief of police behind a closed door. After that, the case had been closed, and Frank had been moved to traffic duty for a year. He said that he had a wife and two small children, and that he had been afraid to lose his job. He told the detective that he was sorry, and that he had carried the shame of his silence for ten years. Detective Lawson told him that it was not too late, and that his memory could still help Anna.
Before she left, Frank went to a drawer in his bedroom and took out a small notebook. He said that he had written down everything he remembered about that night, the time, the car, the mud on the floor, and the open gate, because he had been afraid that the file would be lost. He gave the notebook to Detective Lawson, and he told her to use it however she needed to. She thanked him warmly, and she drove back to the station with the notebook on the seat beside her. She knew now that the truth had been buried for ten years. She would dig it up, whatever it cost.