A Choice at the Table
On Sunday morning, Emily Carter set the kitchen table for four people, just as her mother had done when she was a child. She put out the white plates and the blue cups, and she made tea the way her father had liked it, strong and hot. Ethan Parker sat at one end, Tom Bennett at the other, and Detective Sarah Lawson sat by the window, with her notebook open in front of her. Grace Miller had brought a loaf of fresh bread, still warm from her oven.
"We have two choices," Lawson said at last, putting down her cup. "We can arrest Hale now, on the evidence we have, and hope that Anna comes forward when she hears the news. Or we can wait, and try to find Anna first, so that she can tell her own story in her own words."
Emily looked down at her hands. "If we arrest him now, he will say the tape is false, and the diary is a child's fantasy," she said. "He has friends in this town, and money, and a good lawyer. He could walk free, and Anna would stay hidden forever, afraid to come home."
"But if we wait," Tom said, "Hale will know we are coming. He could run, or he could destroy more evidence. He has already waited ten years. He will not wait quietly while we search for Anna."
Ethan poured more tea for everyone. "Anna hid because she was afraid," he said. "She hid because Hale told her that her family would suffer if she talked. If we find her first, and we show her that her family is safe, and that Hale cannot hurt her anymore, she will come home. I believe that."
Grace nodded slowly. "I agree with Ethan," she said. "A girl who filmed the truth at seventeen, and hid it so carefully, is a brave girl. She did not run away from her family. She ran away from fear. If we take away the fear, she will come back."
Lawson closed her notebook. "Then we need to find her," she said. "Anna's diary mentions a friend in a nearby town, a girl called Lucy, who worked in a bookshop. Anna wrote that Lucy had offered her a place to stay, if she ever needed it. It is a small clue, but it is the best clue we have."
Emily's eyes lit up. "Lucy Hart," she said. "I remember her. She was Anna's best friend at school. She moved away after Anna disappeared, to a town called Willow Creek, about twenty miles from here. She owns a bookshop there now. If Anna went anywhere, she went to Lucy."
Ethan stood up. "Then we should go to Willow Creek today," he said. "Emily and I can go, and Tom can stay here and watch the house. Lawson, you can keep an eye on Hale, so he does not run."
Lawson shook her head. "I cannot let you go alone," she said. "If Anna is there, she will be afraid. She will need to see a friendly face first, and Emily is the best person for that. But I will come with you, as a detective, not as a threat. I will wait in the car while Emily talks to her sister."
They finished their tea quickly and cleared the table. Emily changed into a clean dress, and she brushed her hair, and she looked at herself in the mirror.
Ethan drove the car, with Emily beside him and Lawson in the back seat. The road to Willow Creek wound through green fields and past small farms. The sun was shining, and the sky was clear. It was a beautiful day for a journey, and Ethan tried to hold on to that thought. He tried not to think about what would happen if Anna was not there, or if she refused to come home.
Lawson parked the car across the street. "Go slowly," she said. "Let Lucy talk first. Let Anna decide. We have waited ten years. We can wait a little longer."
Emily took a deep breath, opened the car door, and stepped out into the sunshine. Ethan watched her walk towards the bookshop, and he prayed silently that the choice they had made at the table was the right one.
Ethan kept the engine running, his hands steady on the wheel, hoping with all his heart that Anna would open the door and come home at last.