The Man at the Lake
The next morning, Ethan Parker drove to the lake before the sun was fully up, and he parked his old car near the trees and walked down the narrow path to the water. The air was cold, and the mist lay low over the lake, and the birds were just beginning to call. He stood in the place where Anna had stood ten years ago, and he tried to imagine her fear, and he tried to imagine the man who had threatened her. He looked at the ground, and he looked at the trees, and he looked at the water, and he understood why Anna had loved this place, and why she had filmed it so often. It was quiet and beautiful, and it felt far away from the town, and it felt like a place where a girl could be safe. But Ethan knew now that it had not been safe at all.
He walked slowly along the path, and he found a small wooden bench where Anna might have sat, and he found a flat stone where a camera could have rested. He thought about the footage, and about Richard Hale, and about the money from the town fund, and he wondered how many other people in Maplewood knew about the theft and had chosen to say nothing. He wondered if Hale had come to the lake often, and if he had met other people there, and if the lake had become his secret place for secret business. Ethan took photographs of the path and the bench and the water, and he wrote notes in his small notebook, because he knew that Detective Sarah Lawson would want to see the place for herself, and that she would ask him exactly where Anna had stood.
As he turned to leave, Ethan saw a man standing near the trees, and his heart jumped, because for a moment he thought it was Richard Hale. The man was tall, and he wore a dark coat, and he was watching Ethan. Ethan stopped, and he waited, and the man walked slowly toward him, and he introduced himself as Henry Cole, a fisherman who had lived near the lake for many years. Henry said that he had seen Ethan walking the path, and that he had wondered if Ethan was looking for something, or someone. Ethan told him that he was working on the old Carter house, and that he was interested in the lake, and Henry nodded, as if that answer made sense to him.
Henry told Ethan that he had been fishing at the lake on the night Anna disappeared, and that he had seen a man in a dark coat arguing with a young girl near the water. He said that he had been too far away to hear the words, but that he had seen the girl run, and that he had seen the man pick something up from the ground. Henry said that he had told the police at the time, but that they had thanked him and never returned. He said that he had seen the same man at the lake many times since, always alone, always looking at the water, as if he were waiting for something to rise up from the deep. Ethan asked him if he knew the man's name, and Henry said that he did not, but that the man drove a black car with a town hall sticker on the window.
Ethan thanked Henry, and he wrote down everything the fisherman had said, and he drove back to Maplewood with a feeling that the pieces were coming together. He went straight to the police station, and he asked to see Detective Sarah Lawson, and he told her about Grace Miller, and about Henry Cole, and about the footage on the camera. Lawson listened carefully, and she did not interrupt, and she wrote notes in a neat hand. She said that she had always doubted the story about Anna running away, and that she had wanted to reopen the case for years, but that she had needed proof. Ethan gave her the copy of the tape, and he told her about the black car, and about the town fund, and about Richard Hale. Lawson thanked him, and she told him to be careful, and she told him that she would watch Hale, and that she would protect Emily, and that the truth was finally coming out of the dark.