The Man at the Gate
He carried his tool bag down the stairs and stepped out into the cold morning air. Then he stopped. A man was standing at the gate of the small yard behind the hardware store. He wore a dark suit and a grey coat, and he held a leather folder under his arm. Ethan knew him at once. It was Richard Hale.
"Good morning, Ethan," Richard said, with a smile that did not reach his eyes. "I hope I am not too early. I wanted a word with you before your day begins."
Ethan's heart beat hard, but he kept his voice steady. "Morning, Mr. Hale. What can I do for you?"
"I am sure you are," Richard said. "But old houses also hold old things. Papers. Photographs. Sometimes things that belong to a family, and to no one else. If you find anything like that, I hope you will bring it to me. As Emily's uncle, and as a councilman, it is my duty to look after the family."
Ethan nodded slowly. "If I find anything that belongs to the family, I will give it to Emily. She is the owner now."
Richard's smile faded a little. "Emily is young, Ethan. She does not always understand what is best. Some things are better left in the past. Digging them up only hurts people. Do you understand me?"
"I understand that you are asking me to hide something," Ethan said quietly. "I cannot promise that."
Richard stepped closer. His voice was soft, but there was steel in it. "Let me be plain. Ten years ago, my niece Anna ran away from home. It broke this family. It broke her mother. The town has finally begun to heal. I will not let a handyman with a hammer stir it all up again. Do you know what happened to the last man who tried to ask questions about Anna?"
Ethan did not answer. He had never heard of such a man, and he was not sure one had ever existed. Richard was watching his face, waiting for fear.
"He left Maplewood," Richard said. "He left in a hurry, and he never came back. I would hate for the same thing to happen to you. You seem like a decent young man. You have work here. You have friends here. Do not throw that away."
At that moment, the door of the hardware store opened, and Tom Bennett stepped out. He was Ethan's oldest friend in Maplewood, a broad man with kind eyes and a loud voice. He looked from Ethan to Richard and back again.
"Morning, Mr. Hale," Tom said cheerfully. "Are you buying nails this early, or just enjoying the cold?"
Richard turned, and his smile returned at once. "Just a friendly word with Ethan, Tom. Nothing more. I was telling him how much the town values his work."
Tom nodded, but his eyes stayed sharp. "Ethan does good work. Everyone knows it. Is there anything else, Mr. Hale?"
"No," Richard said. "That is all. Ethan, remember what I said. Bring anything you find to me. It will be better for everyone. Good day to you both."
Ethan hesitated. He had promised Emily to tell no one, but Tom was his friend, and Tom had seen Richard at the gate. "He was asking about the house," Ethan said at last. "He wanted to know if I had found anything in the walls."
"And have you?" Tom asked.
Tom stared at him. "Ethan, you are frightening me. What is going on?"
"I cannot tell you yet," Ethan said. "But I need you to trust me. Today, at ten o'clock, Emily and I are going to Grace Miller's cottage. If Richard follows us, I need you to know where we are."
Tom nodded slowly. "I will trust you. But I am coming with you, Ethan. Not inside. I will wait outside, in my truck. If Hale shows up, I will be there."
Ethan wanted to argue, but he knew Tom would not listen. "All right," he said. "Outside only. And Tom, thank you."
He was ready now.
They shook hands, and Ethan picked up his tool bag. The camera and the diary were still safe. He would take them both to Grace's cottage at ten. Richard Hale had come to his gate to frighten him, but he had only made Ethan more certain. Whatever was on that tape, it mattered. And whatever Richard was hiding, it was worth finding.