What Emily Was Hiding
They found the second tape under the old oak tree, buried in a small metal box. Ethan dug with his hands, and the cold earth came away in clumps. The box was rusty, but it was still closed tight. Inside, wrapped in plastic, was a video tape, and a folded piece of paper.
Detective Sarah Lawson opened the paper first. It was a letter from Anna Carter, written in the same neat handwriting as her diary.
"If you found this, I am still alive," the letter began. "I left Maplewood the night Uncle Richard threatened me. I did not run away because I wanted to. I ran because I was afraid he would hurt me, and hurt Emily too. I changed my name, and I have been living in a small town near the coast, working in a bookshop. I have wanted to come home every day, but I was afraid no one would believe me. I was afraid Uncle Richard would find me."
Emily read the letter twice, and then she pressed it to her chest and cried. Detective Lawson put a hand on Emily's shoulder and waited.
Emily wiped her eyes. "There is something else," she said. "Something I have been hiding too. I knew Anna was alive. I have known for three years."
Ethan stared at her. "What?" he said. "You knew?"
Emily nodded slowly. "Three years ago, I received a letter with no return address. It was from Anna. She told me she was alive, and that she was safe, but that she could not come home while Uncle Richard was still powerful in Maplewood. She asked me not to tell anyone, because she was afraid he would find her. I promised I would keep her secret."
"Why did you beg me not to watch the camera?" Ethan asked.
"Because I was afraid," Emily said. "I was afraid that if the truth came out, Uncle Richard would hurt Anna before anyone could help her. I was afraid that if I told the police, they would not believe me, just as they did not believe Anna. I thought that if I kept quiet, Anna would stay safe. But I was wrong. Keeping quiet only helped my uncle. It did not help my sister."
Detective Lawson listened carefully. "Emily," she said, "you were trying to protect your sister. That is not a crime. But now we need your help. We need to find Anna, and we need to bring her home. Do you know where she is?"
Emily nodded. "She lives in a town called Seabrook, by the coast. She works in a bookshop there, under the name Sarah Miller. I have her address. I have kept it in my purse for three years, waiting for the day when it would be safe to use it."
Detective Lawson took out her phone. "I will call the police in Seabrook," she said. "I will ask them to go to the bookshop and to keep Anna safe. And I will call the station here. Richard Hale will be arrested today. He will answer for what he did to Anna, and for the lies he told this town for ten years."
That afternoon, Richard Hale was brought to the police station in Maplewood. He was still wearing his suit, and he still looked like a respected councilman, but his hands were shaking. When Detective Lawson showed him the tape, his face went pale. He did not speak. He did not need to. The tape spoke for him.
Emily sat in the living room with Ethan and Grace, waiting for news from Seabrook. The house was quiet, but it did not feel empty anymore. It felt as if Anna was already on her way home.
At last, Detective Lawson's phone rang. She listened, and then she smiled. "Anna is safe," she said. "The police in Seabrook found her at the bookshop. She is coming home tomorrow. She wants to see her sister."
Emily closed her eyes and breathed out, as if she had been holding her breath for ten years. "Thank you," she whispered. "Thank you for finding her. Thank you for believing her."
Ethan looked at Emily, and he understood at last what she had been hiding. It was not guilt, and it was not shame. It was love, and fear, and hope, all mixed together. She had kept Anna's secret to protect her, and now, at last, she could stop hiding, and Anna could come home.