The Second Tape
Emily Carter arrived at the house less than an hour after Ethan called her. She came in her car, driving fast, and she did not knock. She walked straight into the hall, her coat still buttoned, her eyes wide with fear.
"Where is it?" she asked. "Where is the diary?"
Ethan held out the small blue book. Emily took it with both hands, as if it might break. She opened it and read the first page, and tears filled her eyes.
"She wrote this," Emily whispered. "This is Anna's handwriting. I know it. I have not seen it for ten years."
Ethan nodded. "There is more," he said. "Anna wrote that she hid her camera in the wall behind her bed. I found it there. I have not watched it. I promised you I would call first, and I did."
Emily looked at the camera in Ethan's bag. She stepped back, as if it might hurt her.
"I begged you not to watch it," she said. "I was afraid of what it would show. I was afraid it would show Anna arguing with our uncle, and that it would ruin our family. But now I have read her diary, and I know she was afraid too. She was afraid of him, and she still faced him. I cannot be more afraid than she was."
Ethan put a hand on her shoulder. "We do not have to watch it alone," he said. "We can call Detective Sarah Lawson. She is honest, and she can help us. Tom told me she has wanted to reopen Anna's case for years."
Emily was quiet for a long time. Then she nodded. "Call her," she said. "Call her now."
Ethan called Detective Lawson, and she arrived within the hour. She listened while Ethan told her about the diary and the camera, and she read the last entries in Anna's diary with care.
"This changes everything," Detective Lawson said. "For ten years, this case was closed. Everyone believed Anna ran away. But this diary says she was threatened by Richard Hale, and that she hid a camera to prove it. We need to watch that tape, but we must do it properly, with a witness, and with the tape kept safe."
They sat together in the living room of the Carter house. The curtains were drawn, and the room was quiet. Ethan connected the old camera to a small screen. His hands were shaking. Emily sat beside him, holding the diary tight. Detective Lawson sat across from them, with her notebook open.
Ethan pressed play.
The screen showed Anna Carter, seventeen years old, sitting on her bed with the camera in her hands. She looked straight into the lens.
"If you are watching this, something has happened to me," Anna said. "I am not running away. I want everyone to know that. My uncle, Richard Hale, has been stealing money from my father's business. I saw him take papers from the study. When I told him I would tell my father, he said I would ruin our family. He said I should leave Maplewood and never come back."
The tape continued. Anna turned the camera toward the door. Richard Hale came into the room. He was angry. He told Anna to give him the camera. Anna refused. He grabbed her arm, and she cried out. Then he lowered his voice and said, "If you tell anyone, I will make sure no one believes you. I will tell the police you ran away, and everyone will believe me, because I am a councilman and you are only a child."
The tape ended. The room was silent. No one spoke for a long time.
Emily looked up. "Where?" she asked. "Where did she hide it?"
Ethan opened the diary to the last page. In the corner, in small writing, Anna had drawn a picture of a tree, with a cross under it. "The old oak," Emily whispered. "The old oak tree in the back garden. Anna and I used to hide things there when we were children."
Ethan, Emily, and Detective Lawson walked out into the garden together. The old oak tree stood at the far end, its branches bare against the grey sky. Ethan felt his own heart beating very fast. Somewhere under that tree, Anna had hidden a second tape, and that tape might hold the answer to the question they had all been asking for ten years: where was Anna Carter now?